仲裁裁决免证效力的反思

Reflections on the evidence-free effect of arbitration awards

生效仲裁裁决确认的事实属于免证事实,分析在司法实践中仲裁裁决的免证规范适用存在的问题及其产生的原因,辅之以比较法研究,将生效仲裁裁决的免证效力认定为证明效力较为合理,在适用范围上应当将主体限定为当事人同一,将客体限定为经过充分质证的事实,构建多元矛盾纠纷化解格局。

The fact confirmed by an effective arbitration award belongs to the category of evidence-free facts.This thesis analyzes the problems and reasons for the application of evidentiary norms in arbitration awards in judicial practice.Assisted by comparative law research,it is more reasonable to recognize the evidence-free effect of effective arbitration awards as evidentiary effect.In terms of application scope,the subject should be limited to the same party and the object should be limited to facts that have been fully verified.This will help to construct a diversified pattern for resolving conflicts and disputes.