不同载荷条件下三种内固定方式治疗PauwelsⅢ型股骨颈骨折的有限元分析

Finite element analysis of three internal fixation modalities for treatment of Pauwels type III femoral neck fractures under different loading conditions

背景:治疗PauwelsⅢ型股骨颈骨折的最佳内固定方式仍未达成共识,既往相关有限元分析大多采用单一简化载荷条件,对于常用内固定装置的生物力学特性还需进一步探究。目的:通过有限元方法分析空心加压螺钉、动力髋螺钉和股骨颈系统治疗PauwelsⅢ型股骨颈骨折在单腿站立载荷及侧方跌倒载荷条件下的生物力学特性。方法:通过CT扫描获取健康成人股骨DICOM数据,导入Mimics 15.0软件,得到骨组织的粗糙模型,再通过Geomagics软件对Mimics导出的数据进行优化处理,然后根据空心加压螺钉、动力髋螺钉和股骨颈系统的临床应用参数采用Pro/E软件建立3种内固定模型并与股骨模型组装,最后导入Ansys软件进行加载、计算,分析3种内固定模型在单腿站立载荷及侧方跌倒载荷的不同工况下股骨和内固定的应力分布和位移情况,以及股骨距和Ward三角区的应力特点。结果与结论:(1)单腿站立载荷及侧方跌倒载荷下,3种内固定模型的股骨近端应力均主要分布在股骨颈骨折端内上方,3种内固定模型的股骨近端、骨折端、Ward三角以及股骨距的应力峰值均为股骨颈系统内固定模型最小,空心加压螺钉内固定模型最大;(2)单腿站立载荷及侧方跌倒载荷下,3种内固定模型的股骨近端位移峰值均位于股骨头顶端,且位移峰值均为股骨颈系统内固定模型最小,空心加压螺钉内固定模型最大;(3)3种内固定模型在单腿站立及侧方跌倒载荷条件下内固定的位移峰值均位于内固定装置上方顶端,且位移峰值均为股骨颈系统内固定模型最小,空心加压螺钉内固定模型最大;(4)3种内固定模型在单腿站立及侧方跌倒载荷条件下内固定的应力均主要集中在内固定装置的骨折端附近区域,且内固定应力峰值均为股骨颈系统内固定模型最小,空心加压螺钉内固定模型最大;(5)结果表明,股骨颈系统的机械稳定性最佳,但是可能存在对于骨折端和股骨距应力遮挡的风险;股骨颈系统的内固定装置应力更为分散,内固定断裂风险更低。

BACKGROUND:There is still no consensus on the optimal internal fixation for the treatment of Pauwels III femoral neck fracture,and most of the related finite element analyses have been performed using a single simplified loading condition,and the biomechanical properties of commonly used internal fixation devices need to be further investigated.OBJECTIVE:To analyze the biomechanical characteristics of Pauwels III femoral neck fractures treated with cannulated compression screw,dynamic hip screw,and femoral neck system by finite element method under different loading conditions of single-leg standing loads and sideways fall loads.METHODS:The DICOM data of healthy adult femur were obtained by CT scanning,imported into Mimics 15.0 software to obtain the rough model of bone tissue.The data exported from Mimics were optimized by Geomagics software,and then three internal fixation models were built and assembled with the femur model according to the parameters of the clinical application of the cannulated compression screw,dynamic hip screw,and femoral neck system by using Pro/E software.Finally,the three internal fixation models were imported into Ansys software for loading and calculation to analyze the stress distribution and displacement of the femur and the internal fixation under different working conditions of single-leg standing loads and sideways fall loads,as well as the stress characteristics of the calcar femorale and Ward’s triangle.RESULTS AND CONCLUSION:(1)Under the single-leg standing load and the sideways fall load,the proximal femoral stress of the three internal fixation models was mainly distributed above the fracture end of the femoral neck.The peak stress of the proximal femoral end,fracture end,Ward triangle,and calcar femorale of the three internal fixation models were the smallest in the femoral neck system model and the largest in the cannulated compression screw model.(2)Under the single-leg standing load and the sideways fall load,the peak displacement of the proximal femur of the three internal fixation models was all located at the top of the femoral head,and the peak displacement was the smallest in the femoral neck system model and the largest in the cannulated compression screw model.(3)The peak displacement of the three internal fixation models was all located at the top of the internal fixation device under the single-leg standing and sideways fall loading conditions,and the peak displacement values were the smallest in the femoral neck system internal fixation model and the largest in the cannulated compression screw internal fixation model.(4)The internal fixation stress of the three internal fixation models was mainly distributed in the area near the fracture end of the internal fixation device under the single-leg standing and sideways fall loads,and the peak value of internal fixation stress was the smallest in the femoral neck system model and the largest in the cannulated compression screw model.(5)These results suggest that the mechanical stability of the femoral neck system is the best,but there may be a risk of stress shielding of the fracture end and calcar femorale.The stress of the internal fixation device of the femoral neck system is more dispersed,and the risk of internal fixation break is lower.