浅谈非法行医的法律适用——对一起未取得《医疗机构执业许可证》擅自开展诊疗活动案的分析与思考

The legal application of illegal medical practice:A case of carrying out diagnosis and treatment activities without obtaining the"Medical Institution Practicing License"

阐述了一起无行医资格的人未取得医疗机构执业许可证擅自开展中医诊疗活动案件,并对该案进行分析,讨论了本案在中医诊疗行为的判断、违法事实认定、法律适用等方面的问题,针对执法实践中医疗器械的鉴别、“一事不再罚原则”的适用、电子证据的合法性等进行了深入思考,参照国外想象竞合的明示机制对卫生监督执法中作出行政处罚提出了合理化建议。

This paper expounded a case of persons without medical qualifications carry out medical diagnosis and treatment activities without obtaining medical institution license.Meanwhile,it analyzes the case and discusses the problems in judgment of traditional Chinese medicine diagnosis and treatment behavior,determination of illegal facts,and application of law,etc.The author deeply considered the identification of medical instruments in law enforcement practice,the application of the principle of"no longer punishment for one case",and the legality of electronic evidence.With reference to the explicit mechanism of imaginative concurrence in foreign countries,this paper puts forward reasonable suggestions on the making of administrative punishment in health supervision and law enforcement.