电信网络诈骗治理中考核计分机制的分析与反思——以某区某高校做法为例

Analysis and Reflection on the Assessment and Scoring Mechanism in Telecommunications Network Fraud Management-Taking the Practice of a Certain University in a Certain District as an Example

在电信网络诈骗犯罪的治理中,刑事政策的主体与表现形式逐渐呈现出多样化的态势。其中某区以及该区内的某高校为推进并监督电信网络诈骗治理工作的开展,设立了针对不同对象的考核计分机制。在分析考核机制的具体内容时发现,计分考核的要求规定的确能够在一定程度上有效预防犯罪的发生,并且能够为治理电信网络诈骗做出实质性贡献,但同时该机制也存在着诸如内容僵化、具体要求有待改进、考核结果落实不到位等问题。因此,为了能够最大程度发挥其监督保障的作用,需对该考核计分机制做进一步完善,以助力有关刑事政策的贯彻落实。

In the governance of telecommunications network fraud crimes,the subjects and manifestations of criminal policies have gradually shown a diversified trend.In order to promote and supervise the development of telecommunications network fraud control,a certain district and a certain university in the district have established an assessment and scoring mechanism for different objects.When analyzing the specific content of the assessment mechanism,it was found that the requirements for scoring assessment can indeed effectively prevent the occurrence of crimes to a certain extent and can make substantial contributions to the control of telecommunications network fraud.However,at the same time,the mechanism also has content such as Rigidity,specific requirements need to be improved,and assessment results are not implemented in place.Therefore,in order to maximize its supervisory and protective role,the assessment and scoring mechanism needs to be further improved to facilitate the implementation of relevant criminal policies.