深度融合背景下出版学科理论应用、主题关注与方法选择——基于9种CSSCI期刊的文献计量分析

Theory Application,Topic Concern and Method Selection of Publishing Subject Under the Background of Deep Integration——Bibliometric Analysis Based on 9 CSSCI Journals

探讨出版学科论文的理论建构、研究主题和方法应用情况,以加强出版学科理论建设,促进跨学科方法论的对话,推动出版业深度融合进程。文章运用文献计量法和内容分析法,对9种出版学CSSCI期刊2023年发表的论文所采用的理论、研究主题和方法进行了统计与关联分析。研究发现:出版研究呈现跨学科理论应用的多元性特点,叙事理论、空间理论、价值共创理论的使用频率最高;研究主题主要聚焦于四个核心方面,包括科技期刊与学术标准、出版业的高质量发展与国际化、学术出版与媒体融合、数字出版与技术伦理;非实证类研究占据主导,实证研究中质化方法应用较为显著,缺乏理论应用的论文也显示出规范的科学研究方法特征。这些研究发现反映了出版学科研究的应用性和实践性、研究主题呈现聚焦性并关切现实问题,以及偏重宏观论述分析、重视实证数据等特色。为促进出版学领域理论与实践的平衡发展,文章从推动学界与出版行业的对话与深度合作、加强理论研究的深度与系统性、强化科学方法在出版研究中的应用与规范性三方面提出相关建议。

The theoretical construction of publishing discipline is the focus of academic concern in the recent years.Using the bibliometric method and the content analysis method,this study conducts the statistical and correlation analysis on the theories,research topics and methods used in the papers published in the 9 CSSCI journals of publishing science in 2023.The findings are as follows:publishing research presents the pluralism of interdisciplinary theory application with the narrative theory,space theory and value co-creation theory which are the most frequently used theories;the research topics mainly focus on four core aspects,including scientific journals and academic standards,high-quality development and internationalization of the publishing industry,academic publishing and media integration,and digital publishing and technical ethics;non-empirical research is dominant,the qualitative method of empirical research is more significant,and the papers lacking theory also show the characteristics of the standardized scientific research methods.These research findings reflect the application and practicality of publishing research,the focus of research topics and concerns about practical problems,and the emphasis on the macro analysis and empirical data characteristics.In order to promote the balanced development of theory and practice in the field of publishing science,this paper puts forward relevant suggestions from three aspects:promoting the dialogue and deep cooperation between the academia and the publishing industry,strengthening the depth and systematization of theoretical research,and strengthening the application and standardization of the scientific methods in publishing research.