不同弹性模量计算机辅助设计和计算机辅助制造桩核材料的应力分析

Stress analysis of computer aided design/computer aided manufacture post-core materials with different elastic moduli

背景:桩核修复是牙体缺损修复的一种常规选择,然而不同桩核材料的修复效果存在差异。目的:利用有限元方法评估不同弹性模量桩核修复模型中桩核与牙根黏结剂部位的应力分布情况。方法:在三维建模软件中构建一个三维根管治疗过的上颌中切牙模型,进行全瓷冠修复,修复中的桩核材料分别使用纳米陶瓷树脂(弹性模量12.8 GPa)、复合树脂(弹性模量16 GPa)、混合陶瓷(弹性模量34.7 GPa)、玻璃陶瓷(弹性模量95 GPa)、钛合金(弹性模量112 GPa)和氧化锆(弹性模量209.3 GPa),将模型约束在皮质骨中,在中切牙牙冠舌侧1/3处加载与牙体长轴呈45°的100 N集中力,通过最大主应力分析修复模型中桩核、牙本质及桩与牙根黏结剂的应力分布。结果与结论:(1)当使用弹性模量较高的桩核材料时,修复模型中的桩核应力较集中;当使用弹性模量接近牙本质的桩核材料(纳米陶瓷树脂和复合树脂)时,桩核的应力分布较均匀;无论桩核材料如何,各修复模型中牙本质上的应力分布相似;使用弹性模量更高的桩核时,修复模型中桩与牙根黏结剂处显示出更多的应力集中。(2)纳米陶瓷树脂模型中桩核、牙根及桩与牙根黏结剂处的最大应力值分别为31.00,33.21,0.51 MPa,复合树脂模型中桩核、牙根及桩与牙根黏结剂处的最大应力值分别为36.84,33.14,0.59 MPa,混合陶瓷模型中桩核、牙根及桩与牙根黏结剂处的最大应力值分别为64.05,32.83,1.00 MPa,玻璃陶瓷模型中桩核、牙根及桩与牙根黏结剂处的最大应力值分别为112.30,32.69,1.73 MPa,钛合金模型中桩核、牙根及桩与牙根黏结剂处的最大应力值分别为120.00,32.17,1.86 MPa,氧化锆模型中桩核、牙根及桩与牙根黏结剂处的最大应力值分别为148.80,31.85,2.28 MPa。(3)桩核材料的弹性模量越高,进行桩核修复时桩核处的最大应力值越大,桩核材料弹性模量对修复模型中桩与牙根黏结剂处与牙本质的最大应力值无明显影响。

BACKGROUND:Post and core restoration is a common choice for tooth defects,but the repair effects of various post and core materials are different.OBJECTIVE:To evaluate the stress distribution at the post and core,tooth root,and bonding agent site of post and core models made of different elastic modulus post and core materials using finite element method.METHODS:A three-dimensional root canal treated maxillary central incisor model was built using three-dimensional modeling software,which was restored with a full ceramic crown.The post and core materials in the restoration used nanoceramic resin(elastic modulus=12.8 GPa),composite resin(elastic modulus=16 GPa),hybrid ceramic(elastic modulus=34.7 GPa),glass ceramic(elastic modulus=95 GPa),titanium alloy(elastic modulus=112 GPa),and zirconia(elastic modulus=209.3 GPa).The model was fixed in cortical bone.A 100 N concentrated force of 45°from the long axis of the tooth was applied to 1/3 of the crown and tongue side of the central incisor.The stress distribution of the post and core,dentin,and tooth-root bonding agent in the model was repaired by the maximum principal stress criterion.RESULTS AND CONCLUSION:(1)When the post and core materials with higher elastic modulus was used,the post-core stress in the repair model was more concentrated.When the elastic modulus of the post and core materials(nanoceramic resin and composite resin)was close to dentin,the stress distribution of the post and core was more uniform.The stress distribution of dentin in all restoration models was similar regardless of post and core materials.When the post and core with higher elastic modulus was used,more stress concentration was shown at the post and root bonding agent in the repair model.(2)The maximum stress values at the post and core,tooth root,and the bonding agent site of post and tooth root in the nanoceramic resin model were 31.00,33.21,and 0.51 MPa,respectively.The maximum stress values at the post and core,tooth root,and the bonding agent between the post and tooth root in the composite resin model were 36.84,33.14,and 0.59 MPa,respectively.In the mixed ceramic model,the maximum stress values at the post and core,tooth root,and the bonding agent between the post and tooth root were 64.05,32.83,and 1.00 MPa,respectively.In the glass ceramic model,the maximum stress values at the post and core,tooth root,and the bonding agent between the post and tooth root were 112.30,32.69,and 1.73 MPa,respectively.In the titanium alloy model,the maximum stress values of the post and core,tooth root,and the bonding agent between the post and tooth root were 120.00,32.17,and 1.86 MPa,respectively.In the zirconia model,the maximum stress values of the post and core,tooth root,and the bonding agent between the post and tooth root were 148.80,31.85,and 2.28 MPa,respectively.(3)The higher the elastic modulus of the post and core material,the higher the maximum stress at the post and core during restoration.The elastic modulus of the post and core material had no significant effect on the maximum stress of the dental bonding agent and dentin.