不规范期刊预警系统的运行实践与启示--基于贵州职称评审系统的研究结果

Practice and Inspiration of Non-standard Journal Warning System-Research Results Based on Guizhou Professional Title Evaluation System

针对期刊管理不规范、审核把关不严、商业利益至上等问题,探索设计不规范期刊预警系统。该系统可以辅助评委会组建单位排查不规范期刊,能够对心存侥幸的科研人员起到警示作用,但存在预警判断不够科学、全面、准确的问题。研究不规范期刊预警系统,为开展多层次、多维度研究,为构建更加符合全国学术生态的不规范期刊预警系统提供基础。

In response to issues such as non-standard journal management,lax review and control,and prioritizing commercial interests,a non-standard journal warning system was designed.This system can assist the evaluation committee in organizing units to investigate non-standard journals and serve as a warning to researchers who are taking chances.However,the risk characteristic indicators of the non-standard journal warning system,the verification standards of reviewers,the verification content,and the verification method may lead to an unscientific,incomplete,and inaccurate warning judgment.It is proposed that multi-level and multi-dimensional research will be carried out based on the non-standard journal warning system,so as to provide a theoretical basis for building a non-standard journal warning system that is more in line with the national academic ecology.