毛晋汲古阁刊《史记索隐》志疑

Skeptical Argumentation on Shiji Suoyin Engraved by Mao Jin

明末毛晋刊汲古阁本《史记索隐》单行本刊行以来,在引起学界重视的同时,也受到了一些质疑。本文将《史记》存世的二家注本、三家注本与汲古阁本《史记索隐》进行了全面的校勘,结果使得汲古阁本《史记索隐》暴露出了许多疑点。此本当不是毛晋所说的覆北宋大字刊本,不排除其为毛晋以不全之本加以缝合而形成的一个新本子的可能性。

Since the publication of the Jigu Ge(汲古阁)versioned single volume edition of Shiji Suoyin(《史记索隐》)in the transitional period from Ming to Qing,it has attracted great academic attention and received some queries from the academic community.Based on a comprehensive collation of the two survived annotated editions of Shiji(《史记》)and the Jigu Ge edition of Shiji Suoyin,this article points out that there are more doubts about this edition than we previously thought.This edition cannot be a version based on a Northern Song large character version as Mao Jin(毛晋)claimed.But rather,it is likely a new edition produced by Mao Jin by piecing up sections from different editions.