驳“宋江杀晁盖”——与阳建雄先生商榷

Refuting the Argument That Song Jiang Murdered Chao Gai:A Discussion with Mr.Yang Jianxiong

金圣叹提出晁盖并非死于史文恭之手,而是宋江嫁祸史文恭杀害了晁盖的观点。这一观点被当代学者如阳建雄所支持。阳建雄在《水浒传中晁盖之死因探析》一文中从多个角度论证了宋江是杀害晁盖的主谋。然而,从逻辑层面、战争描写、曾头市的态度以及宋江的行为等多方面进行辨析,发现阳建雄先生的论证存在诸多漏洞。因此,晁盖之死应归咎于史文恭,而非宋江。这一结论符合《水浒传》的整体情节和人物设定。

Jin Shengtan proposed that Chao Gai was not killed by Shi Wengong but by Song Jiang who framed Shi Wengong for the crime.This viewpoint has been supported by contemporary scholars such as Yang Jianxiong.In his article“An Analysis of the Cause of Chao Gai’s Death in Outlaws of the Marsh”,Yang Jianxiong argues from multiple angles that Song Jiang was the mastermind behind Chao Gai’s murder.However,a detailed analysis of the logic,war scenes,Zengtoushi’s attitude and Song Jiang’s behavior reveals numerous flaws in Yang Jianxiong’s reasoning.It concludes that Chao Gai was killed by Shi Wengong rather than by Song Jiang.This conclusion is in line with the overall plot and character settings of Outlaws of the Marsh.