浅议在国际投资仲裁中构建合理审查标准之必要性

Brief Comments on the Necessity of Building Rational Standard of Review in International Investment Arbitration

尽管以ICSID为代表的'投资者一东道国'仲裁机制晚近得到充分发展,其却依然面临'正当性危机',涉及阿根廷的相关仲裁案件也说明了这一点。有鉴于此,仲裁实务界和学界专家提出了各种方案欲进行修补,然而只是参考公法原则进行分析是不够的,更重要的是仲裁庭在裁决时遵从合理的审查标准,这样既能满足国际投资仲裁的特殊性质,亦能在相当程度上符合裁决一致性的需要。

Although the"Investor-State"dispute settlement has achieved great development so far,it still faces the"legitimate crisis",which can also be fully reflected by cases concerning the Argentina government after the economic crises in 2001.On this account,many experts and professors have made various suggestions.Among those suggestions,building the rational standard of review is noteworthy,since it is consistent with the special nature of international investment arbitrations and can improve the consistency and determinacy of the cases.