梅祖麟《有中国特色的汉语历史音韵学》讲辞质疑

An Argument against Mei Zhu-lin's "History of Unique Chinese Phonology

梅祖麟在香港语言学会发表《有中国特色的汉语历史音韵学》讲辞，对章黄学派及王力先生多所贬抑。本文乃针对梅氏讲辞，从七方面为章黄及王力辨误。一、章黄学派的古音学是胡来的吗？二、梅祖麟正式向董同龢先生学过汉语音韵学吗？三、林森二字是什么谐声关系？四、章黄的古音学说不是语言学吗？五、王力真的不懂“同谐声必同部”的道理吗？六、什么是一声之转？七、还要挑起新旧学派之争吗？

Mei Zhu-lin has presented his paper topic 'History of Unique Chinese Phonology', in which he detracts the philiosophies of both the Zhang Huang Group and Prof. Wang li. This paper address those concerns brought up by Mr. Mei Zhu-lin and acts to defend those philosophies. There are seven points to discussion. One.)Does not the Zhang Huang group's archaic Chinese phonology have a legitimate basis? Two.)Has Mei Zhu-lin been taught Prof. Dong Tong-he? Three.)What is the harmonious connection between the two Chinese characters 'lin'(林)and 'sen'(森)？Four.)Is not the Zhang Huang group's archaic Chinese phonology a study in linguistics? Five.)Does Prof. Wang Li not fully understand the theory 'Harmony of words must be in the same category'? Six.)What does the changing of same initial do to a character?Seven.)Must the old and new ways studying Chinese intellectual schools be continuously in conflict with each other?