宽严相济刑事政策视野下管制刑的不足与完善

On Limitations and Perfection of the Control Punishment from Perspective of the Criminal Policy of temper Justice with Mercy

管制刑是我国宽严相济刑事政策"宽"的典型代表,符合轻刑化、非监禁化、行刑社会化的刑罚发展潮流,其价值应当得到充分肯定。但我国《刑法》所规定的管制刑却宽严失衡,存在适用对象和适用条件不明确、执行主体虚化、行刑内容过于宽松而缺乏惩罚性等不足,严重制约了管制刑功能的发挥。因此,应从宽严相济刑事政策的视角出发,在立法上进一步明确管制刑适用的对象和条件、改造管制刑的行刑主体、设立符合我国国情且具有适当惩罚性的管制内容、确立不服从管制的较严厉的法律后果。

The control punishment is a typical representation of temper under the criminal policy of temper justice with merry,it is consistent with the trend of light punishment,Non - imprisonment and socialized execution,which should be affirmed..However,the control punishment in our criminal law has many limitations.Such as,improper in punishment and leniency,ambiguous in the object and terms of applying the control punishment nihility in executive subject of the control punishment, whithout vindictive function in content of the control punishment,ect.. which leading to the restriction of control punishment 's function. Therefore,we should stipulate clearly the object and terms of applying the control punishment,reform the executive subject of the control punishment,establish reasonable control punishment according to our conditions,set legal consequences of violating the execution of control punishment.