中西医结合治疗持续性植物状态的疗效优势

Superiority of the combination of Chinese traditional and Western medicine in treating persistent vegetative states

目的探讨美多芭(多巴丝肼片)、溴隐亭和中药-神经再通口服液对持续性植物状态患者的治疗作用。方法选用持续性植物状态条件的患者30例,单纯随机分为西医治疗组(n=10)、中西医治疗组(n=10)及对照组(n=10)。西医组用美多芭、溴隐亭;中西药治疗组在西药治疗基础上用中药方剂治疗,对照组用安慰剂同法给药。结果西药治疗组:4例患者症状有明显改善,6例无效,总有效率为40%(4/10);中西治疗组:7例症状有改善,3例无效,总有效率为70%(7/10);对照组:1例有效,9例无效,总有效率为10%。结论美多芭、溴隐亭和中药方剂对持续性植物状态患者有显著疗效。

Aim To study the effects of madopar,brom otipine and Chinese drugs in treatment of patien ts with persistent vegetative state(PVS).Methods Thirty cases of PVS,18males and 12fe males,aged25-68years old,were selecte d and di vided randomly into three groups of10cases in each group:group A was tre ated with madopar and bromotipine;group B was treated with madopar,bro mo tipine and Chinese drug;group C was treated with placebo.All the patients wer e followed up for 1.0-2.5years.Results The symptom of PVS markedly reduc ed i n 4cases and un-changed in 6cases of group A.The tota l effective rate was 40%in the group A.The symptom of PVS reduced in 7case s and unchanged i n 3cases of group B.The total effective rate was70%in the group B.The symp tom of PVS reduced in 1case and unchanged in9cases of group C.The total ef-f ective rate was 10%in the group C.Conclusion Madopar,Bromotine and Chinese drug play an important role i n the recovery of the patients with PV S.