《资本论》商品价值理论真的没有逻辑漏洞吗?——对杨玉生教授批评的回应

Aren't There Any Logical Vulnerabilities in Commodity Value Theory in On Capital?——Response to Criticism by Professor YANG Yusheng

研究马克思商品价值理论的科学态度,应当是在实事求是原则的基础上,将其放到现实的社会经济活动之中进行审视,通过对其局限性进行修正和补充,使之能够合理地说明现实社会经济活动的实际情况。爱因斯坦提出的科学理论真理性的评价标准,不仅适用于对自然科学理论真理性的评价,而且也适用于对社会科学理论真理性的评价,自然也适用于对《资本论》商品价值理论真理性的评价。《资本论》商品价值理论的逻辑漏洞是由它的理论前提和历史条件造成的,依据现实的社会经济活动的实际情况对其所作的修补,是真正意义上的坚持马克思主义。

Seeking truth from facts should be the scientific approach to study Marx's commodity value theory.Marx's com-modity value theory should be examined in realistic social and economic activities so as to correct and supplement its limited-ness.Therefore,it can reasonably illustrate the realities of social and economic activities.Einstein's evaluation criteria of the truth of scientific theory is not only applicable to evaluation of the truth of natural scientific theory,but also to evaluation of the truth of social scientific theory.It naturally applies to evaluation of the truth of commodity value theory in the On Capital.The logical vulnerabilities in the On Capital is determined by its theoretical prerequisite and historical situations.The author is real-ly adhering to Marx doctrine by correcting and supplementing its vulnerabilities according to the realistic social and economic activities.