论附带民事赔偿范围的扩张

Extent of supplementary civil compensation

依现行立法 ,附带民事赔偿的范围仅限于物质损失 ,精神损失不包括在内。这种立法设计不能有力地保护被害人的权利。精神损害赔偿不等于人格权商品化 ,既追究刑事责任 ,又追究民事责任 ,不违反一事不再罚原则。

According to present law, the range of supplementary civil compensation is within material damages, not including moral damages. In this system,the right of the injured can not be protected completely. To criticize it,it is necessary to answer the following questions: whether the compensation of moral damages result in the sale of personality; whether it breaks the principle that no one is punished twice for the same offense; whether the civil responsibility is substituted for the criminal responsibility.