能这样“解构”独语句的逻辑魅力吗?——与《从逻辑角度解构“独语句”的魅力》商榷

Can the Logical Charm of One-word Sentence Be Analyzed in This Way?

就独语句能否自带语境、表达语用学中的“意思”,独语句中的独语词的语义是否确定、独语词是否都能表达确定的实体概念,独语句的语义是否确定,独语句能否不产生歧义以及独语句是否具有“有意谓”的“一个话语”的语用功能等问题提出了与《从逻辑角度解构“独语句”的魅力》一文不同的意见。

In the paper, some different opinions are put forward from that stated by the author of the paper Analysis on the Charm of One-Word Sentence from a Logical Point of Vieiv with regard to the following issues: whether ' one-word sentence' can take context with itself and express CR* '(U (FA))' in Pragmatics; whether the semantic meaning of 'one word' in 'one-word sentence' is definite and can express specific concept; whether the semantic meaning of 'one-word sentence' is definite and have no ambiguity; and whether 'one-word sentence' has the pragmatic function.