“物化劳动是剩余价值的主要源泉”的两个缺陷——与钱伯海教授商榷

TWO DEFECTS FROM VIEWPOINTS OF MATERILIZED WORK IS THE MAIN SOURCE OF SURPLUS VALUE: Discuss Some Viewpoints with Professor Qian Bohai

“物化劳动是剩余价值的主要源泉”的观点,从立论基础到论证过程存在着两大缺陷,一是所谓“实际价值也是价值”的论证把价值与使用价值直接等同起来,二是以“斯密教条”为理论基础的所谓其价值构成研究并不能真正证明物化劳动是剩余价值的主要源泉。物化劳动是剩余价值的主要源泉的观点不是对马克思主义劳动价值理论的发展。

The viewpoints of Materilized Work is the Main Source of Surplus Value has two defects from its premise to reasing.One is the viewpoints of Effective Value is Value confuse the value and use value ,and the another is the study of value composing which is based on Smith Doctrine cannot validate the viewpoints of Materilized Work is the Main Source of Surplus Value.The viewpoints of Materilized Work is the Main Source of Surplus Value don't develop Marxist theory about work value.