对马新仿等《用分形方法研究水驱前后岩石的孔隙结构》一文的置疑

Questions on Application of Fractal Method in Studying Pore Structure in Reservoir Rock before and after Waterflooding-A discussion with Mr.MA Xin-fa ng,et al.

马新仿等在《新疆石油地质》2003年第3期发表了《用分形方法研究水驱前后岩石的孔隙结构》一文,该文的主要数学模型及其推导,是文章的最重要的核心部分,是文章的关键所在。但是这些数学模型及其推导,与以前发表过的两篇文献中所建立的数学模型及其推导,几乎完全相同。这是罕见的巧合还是抄袭痕迹的表现,马新仿先生应作出必要的解释。对这一问题,相信广大细心的读者也会做出自己的判断。

Mr.Ma Xin-fang,et al.,published the paper Applicati on of Fractal Method in Studying Pore Structure in Reservoir Rock before and aft er Waterflooding on periodical Xinjiang Petroleum Geology,No.3,2003.The most important part or key point of this paper is the mathematic models and t heir deductions.However,these models and deductions are almost the same to tho se of previously published two literatures written by others.Is this real coin cidence or questionable plagiary?Mr.Ma should make some explanations for them as necessary.It is believed that earnest readers will make a proper judgement of this question.