董仲舒真的没有进化的历史观吗?——答刘付靖的质疑

On Dong Zhongshu's Developmental View of History: a Reply to Liu Fujing

刘付靖的商榷文认为王永祥对董仲舒进化历史观的论述提出了一个"违反矛盾规则的命题",其实这完全是刘付靖自己虚构出来的;她把进化思想仅限定在近代之后,也是违背全部科学史的;认为在神学形式下只能形而上学的历史观,也不符合中、西方的哲学史。

liu thinks in her essay that Wang Yongxiang set forth a proposition against contradiction about the developmental view of history. In fact it is Liu's wrong understanding. Her opinion is against history of science because she restricts developmental thinking within the modern history. In addition, she thinks that metaphysical view of history under the form of theology is also against history of philosophy in China and in the West.