责任刑在防卫过当案件量刑中的制约功能

The Restrictive Function of Punishment Aimed at Culpability in Sentencing of Cases of Excessive Defense

责任刑在防卫过当案件量刑中的刑罚制约需求较一般案件更为激烈。基于防卫过当自身刑罚限制能力、犯罪常态、类推减轻处罚制度,防卫过当案件责任刑幅度的厘定应于法定刑范围内“疵底”选择。

The demand for punishment restriction aimed at culpability in sentencing cases of excessive de-fense is more intense than that in general cases. Based on the limited capacity of punishment in excessive defense cases, the criminal norm, and the analogous system of mitigating penalties, the determination of the extent of punishment for excessive defense cases should fall within the statutory range of penalties while taking into consideration the “bottom of imperfection” principle.