Although wastewater irrigation in agriculture could be a potential adaptation to water scarcity, its effect on crop yield varies in the literature, making it difficult to evaluate its role in global food security comp...Although wastewater irrigation in agriculture could be a potential adaptation to water scarcity, its effect on crop yield varies in the literature, making it difficult to evaluate its role in global food security comprehensively. Using agronomic experiment data from 62 studies between 1987 and 2021, we employ a meta-analysis to analyze the factors contributing to the heterogeneous effects of wastewater irrigation on crop yield. Our findings can be summarized as(1) the mean yield growth effect of wastewater irrigation is 19.7%;(2) domestic and breeding wastewater irrigation could significantly increase crop yield, while industrial wastewater has a negative effect although not significant;(3) high nutrients concentration of domestic wastewater is significantly positively correlated with crop yield;(4) agronomic experiment designs in terms of field experiment, experiment times, and fertilizer use could contribute to the divergent crop yield effects across the studies;(5) there is a publication bias of the research results between the English and Chinese literature;(6) the literature mainly sheds light on the short-run effect, and the long-run impact shall be an important research question in the future.展开更多
基金supported by the National Social Science Fund of China(20CSH048,20AZD024 and 21ZDA062)the National Natural Science Foundation of China(71773099)+1 种基金the Humanities and Social Sciences Project Funded by the Ministry of Education,China(21YJC790110)the Rural Finance Survey of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs,China(05190084)。
文摘Although wastewater irrigation in agriculture could be a potential adaptation to water scarcity, its effect on crop yield varies in the literature, making it difficult to evaluate its role in global food security comprehensively. Using agronomic experiment data from 62 studies between 1987 and 2021, we employ a meta-analysis to analyze the factors contributing to the heterogeneous effects of wastewater irrigation on crop yield. Our findings can be summarized as(1) the mean yield growth effect of wastewater irrigation is 19.7%;(2) domestic and breeding wastewater irrigation could significantly increase crop yield, while industrial wastewater has a negative effect although not significant;(3) high nutrients concentration of domestic wastewater is significantly positively correlated with crop yield;(4) agronomic experiment designs in terms of field experiment, experiment times, and fertilizer use could contribute to the divergent crop yield effects across the studies;(5) there is a publication bias of the research results between the English and Chinese literature;(6) the literature mainly sheds light on the short-run effect, and the long-run impact shall be an important research question in the future.
