Ultrathin endoscope flexibility can predict discomfort associated with unsedated transnasal esophagogastroduodenoscopy

AIM: To evaluate the effects of choice of insertion route and ultrathin endoscope types. METHODS: This prospective study (January-June 2012) included 882 consecutive patients who underwent annual health checkups. Transnasal esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD) was performed in 503 patients and transoral EGD in 235 patients using six types of ultrathin endoscopes. Patients were given a choice of insertion route, either transoral or transnasal, prior to EGD examination. For transoral insertion, the endo-scope was equipped with a thin-type mouthpiece and tongue depressor. Conscious sedation was not used for any patient. EGD-associated discomfort was assessed using a visual analog scale (VAS; no discomfort 0maximum discomfort 10). RESULTS: Rates of preference for transnasal insertion were significantly higher in male (male/female 299/204 vs 118/117) and younger patients (56.8 ± 11.2 years vs 61.3 ± 13.0 years), although no significant difference was found in VAS scores between transoral and transnasal insertion (3.9 ± 2.3 vs 4.1 ± 2.5). Multivariate analysis revealed that gender, age, operator, and endoscope were independent significant predictors of VAS for transnasal insertion, although gender, age, and endoscope were those for transoral insertion. Further analysis revealed only the endoscopic flexibility index (EFI) as an independent significant predictor of VAS for transnasal insertion. Both EFI and tip diameter were independent significant predictors of VAS for transoral insertion. CONCLUSION: Flexibility of ultrathin endoscopes can be a predictor of EGD-associated discomfort, especially in transnasal insertion.

Evaluation of preferable insertion routes for esophagogastroduodenoscopy using ultrathin endoscopes

AIM:To evaluate the discomfort associated with esophagogastroduodenoscopy(EGD)using an ultrathin endoscope through different insertion routes.METHODS:This study(January 2012-March 2013)included 1971 consecutive patients[male/female(M/F),1158/813,57.5±11.9 years]who visited a single institute for annual health checkups.Transnasal EGD was performed in 1394 patients and transoral EGD in 577.EGD-associated discomfort was assessed using a visual analog scale score(VAS score:0-10).RESULTS:Multivariate analysis revealed gender(M vs F:4.02±2.15 vs 5.06±2.43)as the only independent predictor of the VAS score in 180 patients who underwent EGD for the first time;whereas it revealed gender(M vs F 3.60±2.20 vs 4.84±2.37),operator,age group(A:<39 years;B:40-49 years;C:50-59years;D:60-69 years;E:>70 years;A/B/C/D/E:4.99±2.32/4.34±2.49/4.19±2.31/3.99±2.27/3.63±2.31),and type of insertion as independent predictors in the remaining patients.Subanalysis for gender,age group,and insertion route revealed that the VAS score decreased with age regardless of gender and insertion route,was high in female patients regardless of age and insertion route,and was low in males aged over60 years who underwent transoral insertion.CONCLUSION:Although comprehensive analysis revealed that the insertion route may not be an independent predictor of the VAS score,transoral insertion may reduce EGD-associated discomfort in elderly patients.