Objective: To investigate the effect of Yang-warming and Kidney-tonifying Prescription (YKP) on the treatment of steroid-induced avascular necrosis of the femoral head (SANFH) in rabbits. And to further explore whethe...Objective: To investigate the effect of Yang-warming and Kidney-tonifying Prescription (YKP) on the treatment of steroid-induced avascular necrosis of the femoral head (SANFH) in rabbits. And to further explore whether its therapeutic mechanism is related to the expression of HIF-1α and VEGF (angiogenic factors), BMP2 and Osterix (osteogenic factor), CD31 (type H vascular marker) and MMP13 (bone destruction-related factor). Methods: Twenty-seven healthy male New Zealand white rabbits were divided into a normal group, model group, traditional Chinese medcine (TCM) group (clinical equivalent dose group of YKP), miR-130a inhibitor group and TCM + inhibitor group. The SANFH model was established by combining horse serum with methylprednisolone. After the model is successfully established, TCM group was given 6.44 g/kg·d YKP by gavage, and the miR-130a gene inhibitor group was intraperitoneally injected with 25 mg/kg miR-130a inhibitor, locked nucleic acid (LNA)-anti-miR-130a. TCM + inhibitor group was treated with YKP intragastrically and miR-130a inhibitor intraperitoneally. The rabbits in the normal group and the model group were intragastrically administered with normal saline 10 ml/d. Once a day for 4 weeks. The avascular necrosis was detected by HE staining. The contents of HIF-1α, VEGF, BMP2 and Osterix in rabbit tissues were detected by qRT-PCR kit, and the expression of CD31 and MMP13 was detected by immunofluorescence staining. Results: In the normal group, the surface of the cartilage layer of the femoral head was smooth, the bone trabeculae were intact and densely arranged, the cells of each layer were neatly arranged, the morphology of the bone cells, the chondrocytes and the adipocytes were normal. In the model group, cartilage surfaces of the femoral head showed exfoliative cracks. The bone trabecular structure was loose and incomplete, chondrocytes, osteoblasts and bone marrow cells were significantly reduced, and the number of empty bone traps was significantly increased. In the TCM-treated group, more chondrocytes, thicker cartilage layer, and more regular bone trabeculae were detected as compared to model rabbits. In contrast, the cartilage layer was thinner, the destruction and fracture of bone trabeculae was more serious, chondrocytes and osteocytes were decreased as compared to model group. The expression of HIF-1α, VEGF, BMP2, and Osterix in the model group decreased significantly as compared to the normal group (P Conclusion: YKP can regulate the expression of angiogenic-related factors (VEGF and HIF-α), osteogenic-related factors (BMP2 and Osterix), and H-type vascular marker CD31, resulting in increased expressions of VEGF, HIF-α, BMP2, and Osterix, which promote intra-femoral head revascularization. Meanwhile, YKP decreased the expression of bone-destruction-related factor MMP13, thus enhancing the ability of bone tissue to repair itself. Regulation of these molecules’ expression may be one of the mechanisms of YKP in the treatment of hormonal femoral head necrosis.展开更多
Objective： To observe the regulation of Youguiyin （YGY, 右归钦） on the gene expression profile of the rat with steroid-induced femoral head necrosis （sFHN）, for the sake of investigating its molecular mechanism o...Objective： To observe the regulation of Youguiyin （YGY, 右归钦） on the gene expression profile of the rat with steroid-induced femoral head necrosis （sFHN）, for the sake of investigating its molecular mechanism of sFHN prevention and treatment. Methods： All the 30 rats were randomly divided into three groups, the normal control group （A）, the model control group （B）, and the YGY treated group （C）, 10 in each group. After rats in Groups B and C were being made into FHN models with steroid injection, they received a daily intragastdc administration of saline and YGY respectively in equal volume for a total of 6 weeks, while to the unmodeled normal rats in Group A, saline was administered instead. The rats were sacrificed at the terminal of administration; their mRNA from femoral head tissue was extracted and prepared to cDNA probe through inverse transcription for detecting gene expression profile by microarray, outcomes of which was passing fluorescence quantitative PCR verification, and the differential expressed genes were analyzed adopting gene ontology （GO） method. Results： Compared with Group A, the numbers of differential genes found in Groups B and C were 190 and 92, respectively, but the changing trend in the two groups was opposite, mainly manifested as down-regulating in Group B/Group A （GB/GA） and up-regulating in Group C/Group B （GC/GB）. The analysis showed that these differential genes were mainly assigned to cell apoptosis, signal transduction, metabolism, cell proliferation and differentiation, cell cycle, blood coagulation, antioxidant activity, etc. Conclusions： sFHN was regulated by various genes; the regulation of YGY on expressions of these genes and the intra]extra-cellular signaling processes was possibly the molecular mechanism of YGY for preventing/treating sFHN. This study gave an explanation to the effectiveness of Chinese medicine in preventing/treating FHN from aspects of gene expression and enriched the Chinese medicine theory of ＂Kidney （Shen） governing bones＂.展开更多
背景:激素性股骨头坏死是非创伤性股骨头坏死的关键危险因素,近年来发病率逐渐上升,但其具体发病机制尚不清楚,寻找一个合理的动物模型对于疾病研究及治疗至关重要。目的:综述近年来常用的激素性股骨头坏死动物模型,分析不同造模方式和...背景:激素性股骨头坏死是非创伤性股骨头坏死的关键危险因素,近年来发病率逐渐上升,但其具体发病机制尚不清楚,寻找一个合理的动物模型对于疾病研究及治疗至关重要。目的:综述近年来常用的激素性股骨头坏死动物模型,分析不同造模方式和评价标准的优缺点,为后续研究提供参考。方法:以“股骨头坏死,激素性股骨头坏死,动物模型,femoral head necrosis,osteonecrosis of the femoral head,steroid-induced osteonecrosis of the femoral head,animal model”为关键词,在中国知网、万方及Pub Med等数据库中检索2013-2023年发表的文献,根据纳入标准,纳入61篇文献进行综合分析,其中英文文献38篇,中文文献23篇。结果与结论:(1)兔子、大鼠和鸡是目前在激素性股骨头坏死模型研究中应用较多的动物;(2)激素联合脂多糖或马血清建模死亡率低,模型成功率高,稳定性强;(3)组织病理学是评价模型金标准,但需要终止实验,不利于后续实验研究,所以寻找一种无创替代方法仍是未来的努力方向;(4)目前尚未探索出一种理想激素性股骨头坏死动物模型,未来研究者需继续努力早日在该领域实现突破。展开更多
激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced avascular necrosis of the femoral head,SANFH)是一类临床骨科系统常见病与多发病,究其原因是激素的不合理使用造成股骨头缺血缺氧,而最终发展为股骨头坏死。目前来说,对SANFH的治疗尚无临床特效药...激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced avascular necrosis of the femoral head,SANFH)是一类临床骨科系统常见病与多发病,究其原因是激素的不合理使用造成股骨头缺血缺氧,而最终发展为股骨头坏死。目前来说,对SANFH的治疗尚无临床特效药物,但随着研究手段的进步,已发现自噬在该病的致病过程中扮演重要角色,且已明确部分信号通路能够对自噬产生影响。现阶段,中药防治SANFH的研究备受关注,但其作用机制尚不清楚。本文通过查阅相关国内外文献,就自噬(成骨细胞、破骨细胞、线粒体等)与SANFH的发病关系及中药(如黄芪多糖、葛根素、柚皮苷、川芎嗪、淫羊藿苷等中药单体及化合物,以及桂枝芍药知母汤、右归饮、健骨散、骨痹通消方、活血通络汤等中药复方)调节自噬相关信号通路从而改善SANFH进行概述,以期为拓展SANFH的治疗措施及明确中药应用价值提供参考。展开更多
激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced osteonecrosis of the femoral head,SIONFH)是由于糖皮质激素使用不当或过度而引起的髋关节疾病,发病机制尚未统一,临床疗效亦不佳。当前,没有效果明确的药物可以延缓疾病进程,而中医药治疗SIONFH在...激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced osteonecrosis of the femoral head,SIONFH)是由于糖皮质激素使用不当或过度而引起的髋关节疾病,发病机制尚未统一,临床疗效亦不佳。当前,没有效果明确的药物可以延缓疾病进程,而中医药治疗SIONFH在临床上取得一定疗效。即便如此,仍未能完整的从分子生物及细胞生物学角度阐明中药治疗SIONFH的作用机制。转化生长因子-β(TGF-β)/骨形态发生蛋白(BMP)/Smad信号通路的转导是防治SIONFH的研究热点之一,故该文阐明了该信号通路的转导机制以及与SIONFH的联系,检索了基于该通路治疗SIONFH的全部中药及复方并阐述其影响机制。基于中医对SIONFH的认识,现临床上使用补肝肾强筋骨以及活血祛瘀通络类的方药治疗SIONFH,且具有良好的疗效。中药通过调控该通路,可刺激骨髓间充质干细胞成骨分化,降低破骨细胞含量,减少脂肪生成,改善微循环,抗氧化损伤,促进股骨头内血管新生,从而促进股骨头损伤的修复。现基于TGF-β/BMP/Smad信号通路对中医药治疗SIONFH的研究进展做一综述,期许为中医药治疗SIONFH提供理论依据及参考。展开更多
激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced necrosis of the femoral head, SNOFH)是骨科常见难治性疾病,又被视为“不死癌症”,若不及时干预将导致患者面临人工全髋关节置换术的风险。近些年研究证实,“成骨-成血管耦联”途径研究SNOFH发生发...激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced necrosis of the femoral head, SNOFH)是骨科常见难治性疾病,又被视为“不死癌症”,若不及时干预将导致患者面临人工全髋关节置换术的风险。近些年研究证实,“成骨-成血管耦联”途径研究SNOFH发生发展的机制具有重要意义。SNOFH中医病机责之于脾肾亏虚为本,瘀血为病,痰阻为渐,毒聚为损。“成骨-成血管耦联”机制与“瘀去-新生-骨合”中医理论存在高度契合性。越来越多的临床证据表明中医药治疗SNOFH不仅具有疗效显著、不良反应小、价格低廉等优势,还能提高患者生存质量,为促进股骨头血管重建与再生以及股骨头坏死骨修复等发挥重要作用。基于“瘀去-新生-骨合”理论,临床上多采用补肾活血类中药及中药复方用于SNOFH防治,运用“成骨”之健脾补肾药,“成血管”之活血化瘀药,祛除“抑制因素”之化痰药、祛湿药,有步骤、有层次的治疗SNOFH取得显著效果。因此,从“成骨-成血管耦联”角度探讨SNOFH中医药干预的科学内涵已成为当今研究新热点,能够为后续SNOFH的防治研究和新药研发提供理论参考和借鉴。展开更多
目的:激素性股骨头坏死家兔模型是最常用的股骨头坏死动物模型,其股骨头病理学改变与临床较为接近,但目前国内外报道的造模条件、方法和评价标准等均不统一,导致所建立动物模型的科学价值低、难于推广应用。此次研究旨在明确不同造模条...目的:激素性股骨头坏死家兔模型是最常用的股骨头坏死动物模型,其股骨头病理学改变与临床较为接近,但目前国内外报道的造模条件、方法和评价标准等均不统一,导致所建立动物模型的科学价值低、难于推广应用。此次研究旨在明确不同造模条件对激素性股骨头坏死家兔模型建立的影响,分析模型成功建立的适宜条件。方法:检索中国知网、万方、维普、中国生物医学文献服务系统、Web of Science、PubMed和EMbase数据库中截至2022-04-01前有关激素性股骨头坏死家兔造模的文献,依据纳排标准以及文献质量评价等完成对文献的筛选并提取文献中结局指标数据,运用RevMan、Stata和ADDIS统计软件对纳入数据进行Meta分析。结果:(1)最终纳入82篇文献,共1366只家兔纳入研究,激素性股骨头坏死造模方法分为单纯激素法、激素联合脂多糖法和激素联合血清法3种,其中单纯激素法33篇文献,激素联合脂多糖法20篇文献,激素联合血清法29篇文献;(2)Meta分析结果显示,3种造模方法均能显著增加激素性股骨头坏死家兔股骨头空骨陷窝率(P<0.001),显著降低激素性股骨头坏死家兔股骨头骨小梁面积比(P<0.001);各造模方法的空骨陷窝率排序结果为:激素联合脂多糖法>单纯激素法>激素联合血清法>正常组;骨小梁面积比排序结果:正常组>激素联合血清法>单纯激素法>激素联合脂多糖法;(3)亚组分析结果提示:单纯激素诱导的家兔模型空骨陷窝率可能与家兔品种和造模用激素种类有关(组间差异P<0.05),其中新西兰白兔合并效应量高于中国白兔(P<0.05)和日本白兔,地塞米松合并效应量高于其他激素种类;激素联合脂多糖诱导的模型空骨陷窝率与激素种类和脂多糖给药模式有关(组间差异P<0.05),其中甲泼尼龙琥珀酸钠合并效应量显著高于其他激素种类(P<0.05),泼尼松龙合并效应量显著低于其他激素种类(P<0.05),脂多糖100μg/kg×2次的合并效应量显著低于10μg/kg×2次和50μg/kg×2次(P<0.05);激素联合血清诱导的模型空骨陷窝率与激素种类和血清剂量有关(组间差异P<0.05),其中地塞米松磷酸钠合并效应量显著高于其他激素种类(P<0.05),地塞米松合并效应量显著低于其他激素种类(P<0.05),血清“10 mL/kg+6 mL/kg”组合剂量的合并效应量低于其他血清剂量(P<0.05)。结论:(1)以空骨陷窝率和骨小梁面积比作为模型成功建立的判断标准,3种造模方法都可成功构建家兔激素性股骨头坏死模型,其中激素联合脂多糖法最优;(2)选择单纯激素法时建议使用新西兰白兔和地塞米松,选择激素联合脂多糖法时建议使用甲泼尼龙琥珀酸钠和低剂量脂多糖,选择激素联合血清造模法时建议使用地塞米松磷酸钠。展开更多
文摘Objective: To investigate the effect of Yang-warming and Kidney-tonifying Prescription (YKP) on the treatment of steroid-induced avascular necrosis of the femoral head (SANFH) in rabbits. And to further explore whether its therapeutic mechanism is related to the expression of HIF-1α and VEGF (angiogenic factors), BMP2 and Osterix (osteogenic factor), CD31 (type H vascular marker) and MMP13 (bone destruction-related factor). Methods: Twenty-seven healthy male New Zealand white rabbits were divided into a normal group, model group, traditional Chinese medcine (TCM) group (clinical equivalent dose group of YKP), miR-130a inhibitor group and TCM + inhibitor group. The SANFH model was established by combining horse serum with methylprednisolone. After the model is successfully established, TCM group was given 6.44 g/kg·d YKP by gavage, and the miR-130a gene inhibitor group was intraperitoneally injected with 25 mg/kg miR-130a inhibitor, locked nucleic acid (LNA)-anti-miR-130a. TCM + inhibitor group was treated with YKP intragastrically and miR-130a inhibitor intraperitoneally. The rabbits in the normal group and the model group were intragastrically administered with normal saline 10 ml/d. Once a day for 4 weeks. The avascular necrosis was detected by HE staining. The contents of HIF-1α, VEGF, BMP2 and Osterix in rabbit tissues were detected by qRT-PCR kit, and the expression of CD31 and MMP13 was detected by immunofluorescence staining. Results: In the normal group, the surface of the cartilage layer of the femoral head was smooth, the bone trabeculae were intact and densely arranged, the cells of each layer were neatly arranged, the morphology of the bone cells, the chondrocytes and the adipocytes were normal. In the model group, cartilage surfaces of the femoral head showed exfoliative cracks. The bone trabecular structure was loose and incomplete, chondrocytes, osteoblasts and bone marrow cells were significantly reduced, and the number of empty bone traps was significantly increased. In the TCM-treated group, more chondrocytes, thicker cartilage layer, and more regular bone trabeculae were detected as compared to model rabbits. In contrast, the cartilage layer was thinner, the destruction and fracture of bone trabeculae was more serious, chondrocytes and osteocytes were decreased as compared to model group. The expression of HIF-1α, VEGF, BMP2, and Osterix in the model group decreased significantly as compared to the normal group (P Conclusion: YKP can regulate the expression of angiogenic-related factors (VEGF and HIF-α), osteogenic-related factors (BMP2 and Osterix), and H-type vascular marker CD31, resulting in increased expressions of VEGF, HIF-α, BMP2, and Osterix, which promote intra-femoral head revascularization. Meanwhile, YKP decreased the expression of bone-destruction-related factor MMP13, thus enhancing the ability of bone tissue to repair itself. Regulation of these molecules’ expression may be one of the mechanisms of YKP in the treatment of hormonal femoral head necrosis.
基金Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.30672702,No.81072820 and No.30873276)Key Program of Traditional Chinese Medicine of Zhejiang Province (No.2005Z003)
文摘Objective： To observe the regulation of Youguiyin （YGY, 右归钦） on the gene expression profile of the rat with steroid-induced femoral head necrosis （sFHN）, for the sake of investigating its molecular mechanism of sFHN prevention and treatment. Methods： All the 30 rats were randomly divided into three groups, the normal control group （A）, the model control group （B）, and the YGY treated group （C）, 10 in each group. After rats in Groups B and C were being made into FHN models with steroid injection, they received a daily intragastdc administration of saline and YGY respectively in equal volume for a total of 6 weeks, while to the unmodeled normal rats in Group A, saline was administered instead. The rats were sacrificed at the terminal of administration; their mRNA from femoral head tissue was extracted and prepared to cDNA probe through inverse transcription for detecting gene expression profile by microarray, outcomes of which was passing fluorescence quantitative PCR verification, and the differential expressed genes were analyzed adopting gene ontology （GO） method. Results： Compared with Group A, the numbers of differential genes found in Groups B and C were 190 and 92, respectively, but the changing trend in the two groups was opposite, mainly manifested as down-regulating in Group B/Group A （GB/GA） and up-regulating in Group C/Group B （GC/GB）. The analysis showed that these differential genes were mainly assigned to cell apoptosis, signal transduction, metabolism, cell proliferation and differentiation, cell cycle, blood coagulation, antioxidant activity, etc. Conclusions： sFHN was regulated by various genes; the regulation of YGY on expressions of these genes and the intra]extra-cellular signaling processes was possibly the molecular mechanism of YGY for preventing/treating sFHN. This study gave an explanation to the effectiveness of Chinese medicine in preventing/treating FHN from aspects of gene expression and enriched the Chinese medicine theory of ＂Kidney （Shen） governing bones＂.
文摘背景:激素性股骨头坏死是非创伤性股骨头坏死的关键危险因素,近年来发病率逐渐上升,但其具体发病机制尚不清楚,寻找一个合理的动物模型对于疾病研究及治疗至关重要。目的:综述近年来常用的激素性股骨头坏死动物模型,分析不同造模方式和评价标准的优缺点,为后续研究提供参考。方法:以“股骨头坏死,激素性股骨头坏死,动物模型,femoral head necrosis,osteonecrosis of the femoral head,steroid-induced osteonecrosis of the femoral head,animal model”为关键词,在中国知网、万方及Pub Med等数据库中检索2013-2023年发表的文献,根据纳入标准,纳入61篇文献进行综合分析,其中英文文献38篇,中文文献23篇。结果与结论:(1)兔子、大鼠和鸡是目前在激素性股骨头坏死模型研究中应用较多的动物;(2)激素联合脂多糖或马血清建模死亡率低,模型成功率高,稳定性强;(3)组织病理学是评价模型金标准,但需要终止实验,不利于后续实验研究,所以寻找一种无创替代方法仍是未来的努力方向;(4)目前尚未探索出一种理想激素性股骨头坏死动物模型,未来研究者需继续努力早日在该领域实现突破。
文摘激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced avascular necrosis of the femoral head,SANFH)是一类临床骨科系统常见病与多发病,究其原因是激素的不合理使用造成股骨头缺血缺氧,而最终发展为股骨头坏死。目前来说,对SANFH的治疗尚无临床特效药物,但随着研究手段的进步,已发现自噬在该病的致病过程中扮演重要角色,且已明确部分信号通路能够对自噬产生影响。现阶段,中药防治SANFH的研究备受关注,但其作用机制尚不清楚。本文通过查阅相关国内外文献,就自噬(成骨细胞、破骨细胞、线粒体等)与SANFH的发病关系及中药(如黄芪多糖、葛根素、柚皮苷、川芎嗪、淫羊藿苷等中药单体及化合物,以及桂枝芍药知母汤、右归饮、健骨散、骨痹通消方、活血通络汤等中药复方)调节自噬相关信号通路从而改善SANFH进行概述,以期为拓展SANFH的治疗措施及明确中药应用价值提供参考。
文摘激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced osteonecrosis of the femoral head,SIONFH)是由于糖皮质激素使用不当或过度而引起的髋关节疾病,发病机制尚未统一,临床疗效亦不佳。当前,没有效果明确的药物可以延缓疾病进程,而中医药治疗SIONFH在临床上取得一定疗效。即便如此,仍未能完整的从分子生物及细胞生物学角度阐明中药治疗SIONFH的作用机制。转化生长因子-β(TGF-β)/骨形态发生蛋白(BMP)/Smad信号通路的转导是防治SIONFH的研究热点之一,故该文阐明了该信号通路的转导机制以及与SIONFH的联系,检索了基于该通路治疗SIONFH的全部中药及复方并阐述其影响机制。基于中医对SIONFH的认识,现临床上使用补肝肾强筋骨以及活血祛瘀通络类的方药治疗SIONFH,且具有良好的疗效。中药通过调控该通路,可刺激骨髓间充质干细胞成骨分化,降低破骨细胞含量,减少脂肪生成,改善微循环,抗氧化损伤,促进股骨头内血管新生,从而促进股骨头损伤的修复。现基于TGF-β/BMP/Smad信号通路对中医药治疗SIONFH的研究进展做一综述,期许为中医药治疗SIONFH提供理论依据及参考。
文摘激素性股骨头坏死(steroid-induced necrosis of the femoral head, SNOFH)是骨科常见难治性疾病,又被视为“不死癌症”,若不及时干预将导致患者面临人工全髋关节置换术的风险。近些年研究证实,“成骨-成血管耦联”途径研究SNOFH发生发展的机制具有重要意义。SNOFH中医病机责之于脾肾亏虚为本,瘀血为病,痰阻为渐,毒聚为损。“成骨-成血管耦联”机制与“瘀去-新生-骨合”中医理论存在高度契合性。越来越多的临床证据表明中医药治疗SNOFH不仅具有疗效显著、不良反应小、价格低廉等优势,还能提高患者生存质量,为促进股骨头血管重建与再生以及股骨头坏死骨修复等发挥重要作用。基于“瘀去-新生-骨合”理论,临床上多采用补肾活血类中药及中药复方用于SNOFH防治,运用“成骨”之健脾补肾药,“成血管”之活血化瘀药,祛除“抑制因素”之化痰药、祛湿药,有步骤、有层次的治疗SNOFH取得显著效果。因此,从“成骨-成血管耦联”角度探讨SNOFH中医药干预的科学内涵已成为当今研究新热点,能够为后续SNOFH的防治研究和新药研发提供理论参考和借鉴。
文摘目的:激素性股骨头坏死家兔模型是最常用的股骨头坏死动物模型,其股骨头病理学改变与临床较为接近,但目前国内外报道的造模条件、方法和评价标准等均不统一,导致所建立动物模型的科学价值低、难于推广应用。此次研究旨在明确不同造模条件对激素性股骨头坏死家兔模型建立的影响,分析模型成功建立的适宜条件。方法:检索中国知网、万方、维普、中国生物医学文献服务系统、Web of Science、PubMed和EMbase数据库中截至2022-04-01前有关激素性股骨头坏死家兔造模的文献,依据纳排标准以及文献质量评价等完成对文献的筛选并提取文献中结局指标数据,运用RevMan、Stata和ADDIS统计软件对纳入数据进行Meta分析。结果:(1)最终纳入82篇文献,共1366只家兔纳入研究,激素性股骨头坏死造模方法分为单纯激素法、激素联合脂多糖法和激素联合血清法3种,其中单纯激素法33篇文献,激素联合脂多糖法20篇文献,激素联合血清法29篇文献;(2)Meta分析结果显示,3种造模方法均能显著增加激素性股骨头坏死家兔股骨头空骨陷窝率(P<0.001),显著降低激素性股骨头坏死家兔股骨头骨小梁面积比(P<0.001);各造模方法的空骨陷窝率排序结果为:激素联合脂多糖法>单纯激素法>激素联合血清法>正常组;骨小梁面积比排序结果:正常组>激素联合血清法>单纯激素法>激素联合脂多糖法;(3)亚组分析结果提示:单纯激素诱导的家兔模型空骨陷窝率可能与家兔品种和造模用激素种类有关(组间差异P<0.05),其中新西兰白兔合并效应量高于中国白兔(P<0.05)和日本白兔,地塞米松合并效应量高于其他激素种类;激素联合脂多糖诱导的模型空骨陷窝率与激素种类和脂多糖给药模式有关(组间差异P<0.05),其中甲泼尼龙琥珀酸钠合并效应量显著高于其他激素种类(P<0.05),泼尼松龙合并效应量显著低于其他激素种类(P<0.05),脂多糖100μg/kg×2次的合并效应量显著低于10μg/kg×2次和50μg/kg×2次(P<0.05);激素联合血清诱导的模型空骨陷窝率与激素种类和血清剂量有关(组间差异P<0.05),其中地塞米松磷酸钠合并效应量显著高于其他激素种类(P<0.05),地塞米松合并效应量显著低于其他激素种类(P<0.05),血清“10 mL/kg+6 mL/kg”组合剂量的合并效应量低于其他血清剂量(P<0.05)。结论:(1)以空骨陷窝率和骨小梁面积比作为模型成功建立的判断标准,3种造模方法都可成功构建家兔激素性股骨头坏死模型,其中激素联合脂多糖法最优;(2)选择单纯激素法时建议使用新西兰白兔和地塞米松,选择激素联合脂多糖法时建议使用甲泼尼龙琥珀酸钠和低剂量脂多糖,选择激素联合血清造模法时建议使用地塞米松磷酸钠。
