Do alternative stable states exist in large shallow Taihu Lake,China?

Regime shifts from submersed macrophyte dominance to phytoplankton dominance have been widely reported in small-to medium-sized shallow lakes.However,alternative stable states in large shallow lakes(surface area>500 km^(2))remain unconfirmed.To understand the alternative stable states and the main influencing factors of submersed macrophytes in large lakes,the ecosystem states from monitoring data from 1959 to 2019 in large shallow Taihu Lake(2338 km^(2)in average depth of 2.12 m)in China were examined.Changes in submersed macrophyte coverage(C_(Mac))and phytoplankton chlorophyll a(Chl a)in the time series and their relationships with environmental factors were analyzed.During the field investigation from August 2018 to May 2019,nutrients and Chl a showed obvious heterogeneity across the lake,being generally higher in the western and northern areas and lower in the southeast area,while C_(Mac)was only observed in the eastern areas,e.g.,East Taihu Lake,Xukou Bay,and Gonghu Bay.During the long-term monitoring from 1959 to 2019 in the Central Region,Meiliang Bay,and East Taihu Lake,Chl a increased significantly in the time series.C_(Mac)varied slightly among different subareas,always at low levels(<10%)in the Central Region and Meiliang Bay but at relatively high levels in East Taihu Lake(10%–90%).Frequency distributions of response variables had no multimodality except for C_(Mac)in East Taihu Lake,with two peaks between 15%and 20%and between 55%and 60%.A dual relationship was found between Chl a and total phosphorus(TP)in the areas with and without macrophytes,while C_(Mac)showed no relationship with TP,and submersed macrophytes did not flourish in the Central Region and Meiliang Bay even when TP was at very low levels(≈10 mg/m3).Taihu Lake had similar algal turbidity(TurbAlg)as small-to mediumsized lakes but generally presented with higher values of nonalgal turbidity(TurbNonAlg),as did their contribution to total turbidity as a percentage.This study suggested that large shallow Taihu Lake may have no alternative stable states,but more evidence is needed for East Taihu Lake,which was dominated by macrophytes,as it remains unknown whether hysteresis occurs between the processes of eutrophication and oligotrophication.Unfavorable conditions caused by wind might be the main reason due to the absence of submersed macrophytes in Taihu Lake.These results demonstrate that stricter nutrient control is needed to maintain a healthy state or to recover from a decayed state for large lakes.

Synergies between microsites of plant communities and steady-stage alpine meadows on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau

Background:Due to the effects of climate change and overgrazing in recent decades,alternative stable states in the alpine Kobresia meadow degradation process have coexisted in the same geographical and climatic environment,with variations occurring among microsites.Methods:We used a space-for-time substitution approach to explore the synergies of microsite variation according to its numerical characteristics and the proportion of each stable state at various stages of succession in alpine Kobresia meadows on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau.Results:(1)The highest average aboveground biomass in summer was 196.2±20.3 gm^(-2),with significantly higher levels of biomass in≤3.65 sheep unit ha^(-1) than in other levels of grazing intensity,while the parameters showed no significant differences among grazing intensity levels in>3.65 sheep unit ha^(-1).(2)The importance of plant functional groups,aboveground biomass,and niche breadth of Poaceae and Cyperaceae significantly decreased as the grazing intensity increased.(3)The effects of≥0°C accumulated temperature,total precipitation,altitude,longitude,and latitude cumulatively contributed less than 20%of the variation in the distribution of functional group characteristics across microsites.Conclusions:(1)Overgrazing decreases primary production in alpine Kobresia meadows,but ecosystem responses regulate plant community structure and botanical components so as to partially counteract grazing disturbance.(2)Overgrazing changed the proportion of microsites,which in turn led to regime shift in the plant community and subsequent synergies between the microsites of plant communities and their stable states.