The current understanding of major depressive disorder(MDD)and bipolar disorder(BD)is plagued by a cacophony of controversies as evidenced by competing schools to understand MDD/BD.The DSM/ICD taxonomies have cemented...The current understanding of major depressive disorder(MDD)and bipolar disorder(BD)is plagued by a cacophony of controversies as evidenced by competing schools to understand MDD/BD.The DSM/ICD taxonomies have cemented their status as the gold standard for diagnosing MDD/BD.The aim of this review is to discuss the false dogmas that reign in current MDD/BD research with respect to the new,data-driven,machine learning method to model psychiatric illness,namely nomothetic network psychiatry(NNP).This review discusses many false dogmas including:MDD/BD are mind-brain disorders that are best conceptualized using a bio-psycho-social model or mind-brain interactions;mood disorders due to medical disease are attributable to psychosocial stress or chemical imbalances;DSM/ICD are the gold standards to make the MDD/BD diagnosis;severity of illness should be measured using rating scales;clinical remission should be defined using threshold values on rating scale scores;existing diagnostic BD boundaries are too restrictive;and mood disorder spectra are the rule.In contrast,our NNP models show that MDD/BD are not mind-brain or psycho-social but systemic medical disorders;the DSM/ICD taxonomies are counterproductive;a shared core,namely the reoccurrence of illness(ROI),underpins the intertwined recurrence of depressive and manic episodes and suicidal behaviors;mood disorders should be ROI-defined;ROI mediates the effects of nitro-oxidative stress pathways and early lifetime trauma on the phenome of mood disorders;severity of illness and treatment response should be delineated using the NNP-derived causome,pathway,ROI and integrated phenome scores;and MDD and BD are the same illness.展开更多
Around 1900 German philosophy of science had a zenith with different schools.One topic that invited debate and publishing concerned the separation between the natural sciences and the humanities with the social scienc...Around 1900 German philosophy of science had a zenith with different schools.One topic that invited debate and publishing concerned the separation between the natural sciences and the humanities with the social sciences.Does this distinction about methodology or subject matter?Meaning was underlined in the analysis of human affairs.展开更多
基金Supported by the Ratchadapiseksompotch Funds,Faculty of Medicine,Chulalongkorn University,RA61/050.
文摘The current understanding of major depressive disorder(MDD)and bipolar disorder(BD)is plagued by a cacophony of controversies as evidenced by competing schools to understand MDD/BD.The DSM/ICD taxonomies have cemented their status as the gold standard for diagnosing MDD/BD.The aim of this review is to discuss the false dogmas that reign in current MDD/BD research with respect to the new,data-driven,machine learning method to model psychiatric illness,namely nomothetic network psychiatry(NNP).This review discusses many false dogmas including:MDD/BD are mind-brain disorders that are best conceptualized using a bio-psycho-social model or mind-brain interactions;mood disorders due to medical disease are attributable to psychosocial stress or chemical imbalances;DSM/ICD are the gold standards to make the MDD/BD diagnosis;severity of illness should be measured using rating scales;clinical remission should be defined using threshold values on rating scale scores;existing diagnostic BD boundaries are too restrictive;and mood disorder spectra are the rule.In contrast,our NNP models show that MDD/BD are not mind-brain or psycho-social but systemic medical disorders;the DSM/ICD taxonomies are counterproductive;a shared core,namely the reoccurrence of illness(ROI),underpins the intertwined recurrence of depressive and manic episodes and suicidal behaviors;mood disorders should be ROI-defined;ROI mediates the effects of nitro-oxidative stress pathways and early lifetime trauma on the phenome of mood disorders;severity of illness and treatment response should be delineated using the NNP-derived causome,pathway,ROI and integrated phenome scores;and MDD and BD are the same illness.
文摘Around 1900 German philosophy of science had a zenith with different schools.One topic that invited debate and publishing concerned the separation between the natural sciences and the humanities with the social sciences.Does this distinction about methodology or subject matter?Meaning was underlined in the analysis of human affairs.
