I basically agree with the viewpoints of Shanmugam(Journal of Palaeogeography 7(3):197-238,2018)and Zavala(Journal of Palaeogeog raphy 8(3):306-313,2019)who cited,refined and interpreted the definitions of hypopycnal ...I basically agree with the viewpoints of Shanmugam(Journal of Palaeogeography 7(3):197-238,2018)and Zavala(Journal of Palaeogeog raphy 8(3):306-313,2019)who cited,refined and interpreted the definitions of hypopycnal flow,homopycnal flow and hyperpycnal flow.I appreciate two typical case studies of hyperpycnal flows induced by the Yellow River and Yangtze River,and the Gaoping River.The former is a normal type while the latter is catastrophic.They make up a complete knowledge about hyperpycnal flows and hyperpycnites.According to the interpretation of the word "hyperpycnal" from Greek to English,the "hypopycnal flow" should be "less density flow" or "lower density flow"("低密度流"),the "homopycnal flow" should be "equal density flow"("等密度流"),and the"hyperpycnal flow" should be "higher density flow" or "over density flow"("高密度流" or "超密度流").Some geologists called the "hypopycnal flow" as "异轻流"("abnormally light flow")and called the "hyperpycnal flow" as"异重流"("abnormally heavy flow").There are at least more than 10 names or terms about the "density flows" and the "deposits of density flows".It is a problem indeed.In addition,the density could be changed by salinity,temperature and pressure of water.Therefore,the term "density flow" may be problematic either.Another problem is that reliable and irrefutable identification markers of ancient heperpycnites are lacking.We should observe the policy of "A hundred flowers blossom and a hundred schools of thought contend" to discuss these problems and to promote progress and development of hyperpycnal flows and hyperpycnites.展开更多
文摘I basically agree with the viewpoints of Shanmugam(Journal of Palaeogeography 7(3):197-238,2018)and Zavala(Journal of Palaeogeog raphy 8(3):306-313,2019)who cited,refined and interpreted the definitions of hypopycnal flow,homopycnal flow and hyperpycnal flow.I appreciate two typical case studies of hyperpycnal flows induced by the Yellow River and Yangtze River,and the Gaoping River.The former is a normal type while the latter is catastrophic.They make up a complete knowledge about hyperpycnal flows and hyperpycnites.According to the interpretation of the word "hyperpycnal" from Greek to English,the "hypopycnal flow" should be "less density flow" or "lower density flow"("低密度流"),the "homopycnal flow" should be "equal density flow"("等密度流"),and the"hyperpycnal flow" should be "higher density flow" or "over density flow"("高密度流" or "超密度流").Some geologists called the "hypopycnal flow" as "异轻流"("abnormally light flow")and called the "hyperpycnal flow" as"异重流"("abnormally heavy flow").There are at least more than 10 names or terms about the "density flows" and the "deposits of density flows".It is a problem indeed.In addition,the density could be changed by salinity,temperature and pressure of water.Therefore,the term "density flow" may be problematic either.Another problem is that reliable and irrefutable identification markers of ancient heperpycnites are lacking.We should observe the policy of "A hundred flowers blossom and a hundred schools of thought contend" to discuss these problems and to promote progress and development of hyperpycnal flows and hyperpycnites.
