Interlayer repair with porcine small intestinal submucosa versus internal repair with tragus cartilage in endoscopic tympanoplasty

Objective Endoscopic tympanoplasty includes various surgical methods,such as internal repair,interlayer repair,and external overlay.This technique requires autologous materials,allografts,and xenografts,which are used to repair tympanic membrane(TM)perforation.To obtain good results,appropriate surgical methods and repair materials should be selected.This study aims to assess the efficacy of repairing refractory TM perforations in the porcine small intestinal submucosa(SIS)during transcanal endoscopic type I tympanoplasty.Method A retrospective chart review was performed on patients who underwent TM perforation repair with porcine SIS and tragus cartilage between January 2022 and September 2022 at Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital,Zhejiang University School of Medicine.Perforation size,tympanic status,pre-and postoperative symptoms,follow-up data,wound healing rates,and hearing improvement were analysed.Results Of the 115 patients included in the study,56 underwent interlayer repair with porcine SIS of the TM,and 59 patients underwent internal repair with tragus cartilage.No significant difference was found between the two groups at baseline in terms of age,sex,disease course,perforation side,tympanic status,underlying disease,or preoperative infection.The total postoperative effective rate of interlayer implantation with porcine SIS was 91.07%(51 patients),and that of internal implantation with tragus cartilage was 88.14%(52 patients).No significant difference was found in terms of the graft success rate between the two surgical methods(p=0.887).Postoperative pure tone auditory(PTA)and air-bone gap(ABG)density significantly increased in both groups compared with before surgery(p<0.05).However,the postoperative PTA and ABG density were not significantly different 3 months post-surgery between the two groups(p>0.05).Compared to those in the internal implantation group,the patients in the interlayer group had a shorter operation duration(51.36±6.76 min vs.59.71±7.45 min,t=6.298,p<0.001)and less blood loss(11.91±2.61 mL vs.15.27±2.57 mL,t=7.019,p<0.001).Conclusions Our study suggests that the porcine SIS,as well as the tragus cartilage,has a high success rate in repairing irreversible TM perforation.Endoscopic tympanoplasty via interlayer implantation with porcine SIS offers distinct advantages,including the absence of donor-site incision and scar formation,and ease of graft modification and manipulation.

Bone Auditory Thresholds Variations in Cholesteatoma Middle Ear Surgery

Objective: To investigate the changes of bone auditory thresholds variations in cholesteatoma middle ear surgery and its related factors and its related factors. Methods: 122 cases (122 ears) of unilateral cholesteatoma otitis media were treated by mastoidectomy and/or tympanoplasty plus stage I tympanoplasty, and tragus cartilage ring-cartilage membrane (Referred to as cartilage group, 62 ears) and temporalis muscle fascia (Referred to as fascia group, 60 ears) were used as tympanic membrane grafts respectively. The changes of bone conduction hearing threshold were compared between the two groups before and 1, 3, 6 months and 1, 3 years after operation. And compare the difference in the incidence of ossicular chain fixation or necrosis, vestibular window or cochlear window dysfunction between the two groups of patients with increased (positive) and decreased (negative) bone conduction threshold before operation. Results: Compared with the healthy side, 95 ears of 122 ears in the two groups had higher bone conduction hearing threshold before operation. Among them, 48 ears were in cartilage group and 47 ears were in fascia group;In 72 ears (76.34%) of these cases, the bone conduction hearing threshold decreased after operation, and the difference between the two groups was statistically significant (P Conclusion: The improvement of bone conduction hearing threshold in patients with cholesteatoma otitis media is mainly related to the fixation or necrosis of ossicular chain and the dysfunction of two windows. The tragus cartilage ring-perichondrium tympanoplasty can not only reduce the air-bone conduction difference, but also reduce the bone conduction hearing threshold, which has the advantage of stable and lasting hearing improvement.