OBJECTIVE: Two common health care delivery systems in the United States are fe e-for-service and managed care systems, including health maintenance organizat ions (HMOs). Differences may exist in patient outcomes depe...OBJECTIVE: Two common health care delivery systems in the United States are fe e-for-service and managed care systems, including health maintenance organizat ions (HMOs). Differences may exist in patient outcomes depending upon the health care delivery system in which they are enrolled. We evaluated possible differen ces in the stage at diagnosis for breast and cervical cancer between 2 Medicare health care delivery systems (ie, fee for service and HMO) over the period 1985 -2001. METHODS: We used a linkage of 2 national databases: the Medicare databas e from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the National Cancer In stitute’s Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results program database to evalu ate differences in stage at diagnosis between HMO and fee for service for breast and cervical cancer. RESULTS: We studied 130,336 Medicare-aged women with brea st cancer (83%Medicare fee for service) and 6,758 women with cervical cancer (8 7%Medicare fee for service). We found an earlier stage of diagnosis for HMO pat ients, which remained significant after adjusting for potential confounding vari ables. Women enrolled in HMOs with breast cancer were 17%more likely and those with cervical cancer 35%more likely to be diagnosed at an in situ stage of diag nosis than fee-for-service patients. It is of note that when women had other c ancer diagnoses, no statistically significant differences were seen in stage at diagnosis for either cancer between fee-for-service and HMO patients. CONCLUSI ON: Differences exist in stage at diagnosis between Medicare patients enrolled i n HMOs compared with fee for service. This is likely due in part to use of or ac cess to care.展开更多
文摘OBJECTIVE: Two common health care delivery systems in the United States are fe e-for-service and managed care systems, including health maintenance organizat ions (HMOs). Differences may exist in patient outcomes depending upon the health care delivery system in which they are enrolled. We evaluated possible differen ces in the stage at diagnosis for breast and cervical cancer between 2 Medicare health care delivery systems (ie, fee for service and HMO) over the period 1985 -2001. METHODS: We used a linkage of 2 national databases: the Medicare databas e from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the National Cancer In stitute’s Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results program database to evalu ate differences in stage at diagnosis between HMO and fee for service for breast and cervical cancer. RESULTS: We studied 130,336 Medicare-aged women with brea st cancer (83%Medicare fee for service) and 6,758 women with cervical cancer (8 7%Medicare fee for service). We found an earlier stage of diagnosis for HMO pat ients, which remained significant after adjusting for potential confounding vari ables. Women enrolled in HMOs with breast cancer were 17%more likely and those with cervical cancer 35%more likely to be diagnosed at an in situ stage of diag nosis than fee-for-service patients. It is of note that when women had other c ancer diagnoses, no statistically significant differences were seen in stage at diagnosis for either cancer between fee-for-service and HMO patients. CONCLUSI ON: Differences exist in stage at diagnosis between Medicare patients enrolled i n HMOs compared with fee for service. This is likely due in part to use of or ac cess to care.
