目的:评价中国科学引文数据库收录的针灸期刊发表的Meta分析文献方法学质量和报告质量,为相关研究提供借鉴与示范。方法:计算机检索《中国针灸》《针刺研究》,Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science,World Journal of Acupuncture-M...目的:评价中国科学引文数据库收录的针灸期刊发表的Meta分析文献方法学质量和报告质量,为相关研究提供借鉴与示范。方法:计算机检索《中国针灸》《针刺研究》,Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science,World Journal of Acupuncture-Moxibustion杂志2017年12月前发表的Meta分析文献,使用AMSTAR量表进行方法学质量评价,使用PRISMA声明进行报告质量评价。结果:共纳入文献69篇,文献的合著率为100%,合作度为5.45。第一作者来自32个单位,共有29篇(42.0%)文献得到基金资助。文献被引率为98.6%,篇均被引16.3次。方法学质量评价均分为(7.78±1.14)分,高质量14篇(20.3%),中等质量50篇(72.5%),低质量5篇(7.2%)。报告质量评价均分为(20.33±2.36)分,相对完整24篇(34.8%),一定缺陷41篇(59.4%),严重缺陷4篇(5.8%)。结论:中国科学引文数据库针灸期刊发表的Meta分析报告具有较高的方法学质量和报告质量,可以为临床决策提供证据,但仍然需要进一步按照Meta分析报告的规范写作,使质量水平不断提高。同时,应该不断提高试验研究的整体水平,推动针灸循证研究的发展,促进高质量证据的形成。展开更多
OBJECTIVE： To investigate the quality and meth- ods of clinical research literature published in for- eign Science Citation Index （SCI） journals studying the treatment of low back pain with acupuncture. To conduct ...OBJECTIVE： To investigate the quality and meth- ods of clinical research literature published in for- eign Science Citation Index （SCI） journals studying the treatment of low back pain with acupuncture. To conduct a comparative study with clinical re- search literature published in Chinese core domes- tic journals, and to understand the prospects of cur- rent research trends of acupuncture clinical studies in Western countries and China. METHODS： Studies on clinical acupuncture treat- ment of low back pain in English SCI journals and four Chinese core domestic journals dated from 2002 to 2012 were sourced and summarized for this study. Objective analysis and evaluation on the differences in subject and scope of study on low back pain by foreign and Chinese researchers were conducted. RESULTS： Forty-seven English studies and 115 Chi- nese studies met our inclusion criteria. A keyword search revealed different kinds of low back pain re- lated conditions in English and Chinese studies. The English studies were broad in scope, while the Chinese studies were more focused. There were al-so differences in the understanding and definition of concepts and study orientation. CONCI.IJSION： More study should be undertaken to understand the contradictions that acupuncture faces in view of modern research to further ad- vance the field.展开更多
文摘目的:评价中国科学引文数据库收录的针灸期刊发表的Meta分析文献方法学质量和报告质量,为相关研究提供借鉴与示范。方法:计算机检索《中国针灸》《针刺研究》,Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science,World Journal of Acupuncture-Moxibustion杂志2017年12月前发表的Meta分析文献,使用AMSTAR量表进行方法学质量评价,使用PRISMA声明进行报告质量评价。结果:共纳入文献69篇,文献的合著率为100%,合作度为5.45。第一作者来自32个单位,共有29篇(42.0%)文献得到基金资助。文献被引率为98.6%,篇均被引16.3次。方法学质量评价均分为(7.78±1.14)分,高质量14篇(20.3%),中等质量50篇(72.5%),低质量5篇(7.2%)。报告质量评价均分为(20.33±2.36)分,相对完整24篇(34.8%),一定缺陷41篇(59.4%),严重缺陷4篇(5.8%)。结论:中国科学引文数据库针灸期刊发表的Meta分析报告具有较高的方法学质量和报告质量,可以为临床决策提供证据,但仍然需要进一步按照Meta分析报告的规范写作,使质量水平不断提高。同时,应该不断提高试验研究的整体水平,推动针灸循证研究的发展,促进高质量证据的形成。
文摘OBJECTIVE： To investigate the quality and meth- ods of clinical research literature published in for- eign Science Citation Index （SCI） journals studying the treatment of low back pain with acupuncture. To conduct a comparative study with clinical re- search literature published in Chinese core domes- tic journals, and to understand the prospects of cur- rent research trends of acupuncture clinical studies in Western countries and China. METHODS： Studies on clinical acupuncture treat- ment of low back pain in English SCI journals and four Chinese core domestic journals dated from 2002 to 2012 were sourced and summarized for this study. Objective analysis and evaluation on the differences in subject and scope of study on low back pain by foreign and Chinese researchers were conducted. RESULTS： Forty-seven English studies and 115 Chi- nese studies met our inclusion criteria. A keyword search revealed different kinds of low back pain re- lated conditions in English and Chinese studies. The English studies were broad in scope, while the Chinese studies were more focused. There were al-so differences in the understanding and definition of concepts and study orientation. CONCI.IJSION： More study should be undertaken to understand the contradictions that acupuncture faces in view of modern research to further ad- vance the field.
