Effect of Chinese Herbs for Activating Blood Circulation,Removing Stasis and Supplementing Qi on the Circulating Endothelial Cells in Patients with Unstable Angina Pectoris

Objective: To observe the effect and clinical significance of circulating endothelial cells (CEC) in the pathogenesis of coronary heart disease with unstable angina pectoris (CHD-UAP), and to explore the protective effect of Chinese herbs for activating blood circulation, removing stasis and supplementing Qi (CH) on CHD-UAP patient's CEC. Methods: Sixty patients with diagnosis of CHD-UAP confirmed and differentiated to be Qi-deficiency and blood stasis by TCM were randomly divided into two groups and treated, on the basis of Western drug-therapy, with Tongxinluo capsule (通心络胶囊, TXL) and Huoxue Tongmai capsule (活血通脉胶囊, HXTM) respectively by way of oral taking three times a day, 3 capsules every time, with 1 month as one therapeutic course. The number of CEC in patients' blood circulation was counted before and after treatment. Besides, the number of CEC in 30 healthy persons was also counted for control. Results: The number of CEC in CHD-UAP patients was significantly higher than that in the healthy persons (P<0.01). After the patients were treated with CH, either TXL or HXTM, it significantly decreased (P<0.01)with insignificant difference between the two treated groups. Conclusion: CEC in CHD-UAP patients is severely damaged and endothelial function in disorder, Chinese herbs have protective effect on patients' CEC.

Clinical and experimental study of effect of Raondix Salviae Militiorrhiza and other blood activating and stasis eliminating Chinese herbs on hemodynamics of portal hypertension

AIM To study the effects of Radix Salviae Militiorrhiza (RSM), other blood-activating and stasis-eliminating Chinese herbs on hemodynamics of portal hypertension.METHODS Portal pressure of cirrhotic dogs after chronic common bile duct ligation was measured directly; portal blood flow in patients with liver cirrhosis were detected by ultrasound Doppler.RESULTS After administration of RSM and Radix Angelicae Sinensis (RAS) by intravenous infusion in cirrhosis dogs, the portal venous pressure (Ppv), wedge hepatic venous pressure (WHVP), hepatic venous pressure gradient (HVPG), were significantly decreased (P＜0.05-0.01), but the mean arterial pressure (MAP), and the heart rate (HR) remained unchanged. When nifedipine was used, Ppv, WHVP, MAP and HR were significantly decreased (P＜0.05), and the MVPG unchanged (P＞0.05). After administration of RSM, RSM+nifedipine and RSM+Hirudin+Nifedpin for 10-12 weeks, the diameter of portal vein (Dpv), spleen vein (Dsv), the portal venous flow (Qpv) and splenic venous flow (Qsv) in patients with hepatic cirrhosis were significantly lowered (P＜0.05-0.01), and the effect of RAS was weaker.CONCLUSIONS The efficacy of decreasing Ppv by Chinese herbs-RSM, RAS, etc. as compared with nifedipine, demonstrated that the Chinese herbs were slower in action than that of nifedipine, but more long-lasting and without side effects. Hence, long-term administration of Chinese herbs, would be more beneficial.

Treatment of Hypertensive Cerebral Hemorrhage by Activating Blood Circulation to Remove Stasis

The treatment of hy-pertensive cerebral hemorrhage(HCH)by activatingblood circulation to removestasis(ABCRS)is a newtherapeutic approach,which is initiated by clinical specialists of TCM andintegrative Chinese andwestern medicine.Al-though it is not a flawless

Clinical Experience in the Treatment of Vitiligo by the Method of Invigorating Qi,Promoting Blood Circulation and Detoxification

Studies have shown that traditional Chinese medicines have clear curative effects in the treatment of vitiligo with few side effects.Through literature research and clinical observation,the study summarized the etiology and pathogenesis of vitiligo in traditional Chinese medicine as"deficiency,toxin,and stasis",formulated the method of invigorating qi,promoting blood circulation and detoxification,and prescribed Fuse Hexue Jiawei Decoction for the treatment of vitiligo.

Study on the Protective Effects of Compound Blood-activating Soup on Bone Marrow Hematopoietic Cells in Acute Radiation Injured Mice

After irradiation with 8 Gy 60Coγ-ray,mice were immediaterly given intraperitoneal injection of 200 mg 100 % compound blood-activating soup twice a day. On the 3rd and 7th day, the P53 gene expression of bone marrow hematopoietic cells in Chinese drug group was found to be higher than that in normal group, and it was also significantly higher than that in control group. The expression level of GADD153 gene which was not expressed in normal group was much lower in Chinese drug group than that in control group. On the 7th day after irradiation, the P53 and GADD153 gene expression levels of splenic mononuclear cells were consistent with those of bone marrow hematopoietic cells both in Chinese drug group and control group. On the 3rd and 7th day, the bone marrow hematopoietic tissue volume in Chinese drug group was higher than that in control group, with no difference found between the two groups. While on the 14th day, the difference became significant (P＜0. 01). The results showed that commonly used blood-activating and stasis-eliminating drugs may strengthen .the viability of hematopoietic cells and promote the rehabilitation of hematopoiesis by inducing wt-P53 expression to block the bone marrow hematopoietic cells in G1 phase, during which DNA could be repaired.

Exploration of the Effect and Mechanism of Activating Blood Circulation and Stasis-Removing Therapy on Tumor Metastasis

Metastasis is one of the specificities of late stage tumor and also a lethal factor often encountered. The study of tumor metastasis has important meaning for prolonging patients＇ survival and elevating their quality of life, but no really ideal prevention and treatment method has been found so far. Recent researches showed that tumor metastasis is correlated with platelet aggregation and blood hyperviscosity manner. Therefore, the early application of surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy and biological therapies, in combination with Chinese medicine therapy for activating blood circulation and removing stasis （ABCRS） may be, after all, an effective approach. ABCRS therapy is an important therapy of Chinese medicine, which, composed of several methods like smoothening blood flow in vessels, promoting blood circulation and dispersing stagnant blood, could influence tumor metastasis to different extents, and could coordinate with some other Chinese medicine therapeutic methods like supplementing qi, promoting qi, clearing heat, removing toxic substances, warming meridian, dispelling wind, eliminating dampness, nourishing yin, dissolving sputum, relieving stagnancy, emptying viscerals, etc. The effect and acting mechanism of ABCRS on tumor metastasis is summarized in this paper and its bi-directional regulatory effects discussed as well.

Efficacy and safety of activating blood circulation and removing blood stasis of Traditional Chinese Medicine for managing renal fibrosis in patients with chronic kidney disease:a systematic review and Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE:To evaluate the efficacy and safety of activating blood circulation and removing blood stasis in terms of Traditional Chinese Medicine(TCM) for managing renal fibrosis(RF) in patients with chronic kidney disease(CKD).METHODS:We searched randomized controlled trials(RCTs) from eight databases.RESULTS:Sixteen eligible studies with 1,356 participants were included in this study.Compared to treatment with Western Medicine(WM) alone,the combined treatment with activating blood circulation and removing blood stasis in terms of TCM(ARTCM) and WM to manage RF in patients with CKD significantly ameliorated type Ⅳ collagen(C-Ⅳ)(SMD:-2.17,95% CI:3.01 to-1.34),type Ⅲ procollagen(PC-Ⅲ)(SMD:-1.08,95% CI:-1.64 to-0.53),laminin(LN)(SMD:-1.28,95% CI:-1.65 to-0.90),transforming growth factor β 1(TGF-β1)(SMD:-0.65,95% CI:-1.18 to-0.12),serum creatinine(Scr)(SMD:-1.36,95% CI:-1.85 to-0.87),blood urea nitrogen(BUN)(MD:-1.51,95% CI:-2.59 to-0.43),and 24 h urine protein(24h Upro)(SMD:-1.23;95% CI:-1.96 to-0.50).The level of hyaluronic acid(HA) was similar in both types of treatment(SMD:-0.74,95% CI:-1.91 to 0.44).The subgroup analysis showed that the duration of 8 weeks might affect the concentration of C-Ⅳ,PC-Ⅲ,and LN(P < 0.05).The effectiveness of the longer duration to C-Ⅳ,PC-Ⅲ,and LN was not certain.However,the result should be interpreted in care.The safety of the treatment using ARTCM and WM could not be evaluated because a few studies had reported adverse effects.The results of the Meta-analysis were not stable enough.There was publication bias for the reports on Scr(P = 0.001),C-Ⅳ(P = 0.001),PC-Ⅲ(P = 0.026),and LN(P = 0.030) and no publication bias for the reports on BUN(P = 0.293).The quality of evidence varied from low to very low.CONCLUSIONS:The combined treatment using ARTCM and WM to manage RF in patients with CKD has some advantages over treatment with WM alone.High-quality RCTs need to be conducted for the strong support.

Activating Blood Circulation to Remove Stasis Treatment of Hypertensive Intracerebral Hemorrhage:A Multi-Center Prospective Randomized Open-Label Blinded-Endpoint Trial

Objective： To investigate the efficacy and safety of the Chinese herbal therapeutic regimen of activating blood circulation （TRABC） in treatment of hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage （HICH）. Methods： This was a multi-center prospective randomized open-label blinded-endpoint （PROBE） trial with HICH admitted to 12 hospitals. Totally 240 participants were randomized to the treatment group treated with TRABC in addition to conventional Western treatment or the control group with conventional Western treatment equally for 3 months. Primary outcome was degree of disability as measured by modified Rankin Scale （mRS）. Secondary outcomes were the absorption of hematoma and edema, National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale （NIHSS） scores and patient-reported outcome measures for stroke and Barthel activities of daily living index. Adverse events and mortality were also recorded. Results： After 3 months of treatment, the rate of mRS 0-1 and mRS 0-2 in the treatment group was 72.5% and 80.4%, respectively, and in the control group 48.1% and 63.9%, respectively, with a significant difference between groups （P〈0.01）. Hematoma volume decreased significantly at day 7 of treatment in the treatment group than the control group （P=0.038）. Average Barthel scores in the treatment group after treatment was 89.11 ＋ 19.93, and in the control group 82.18 ＋ 24.02 （P=0.003）. NIHSS scores of the two groups after treatment decreased significantly compared with before treatment （P=0.001）. Patient-reported outcomes in the treatment group were lower than the control group at day 21 and 3 months of treatment （P〈0.05）. There were 4 deaths, 2 in each group, and 11 adverse events, 6 in the treatment group and 5 in the control group. Conclusion： The integrative therapy combined TRABC with conventional Western treatment for HICH could promote hematoma absorption thus minimize neurologic impairment, without increasing intracerebral hematoma expansion and re-bleeding.

Effect on platelet aggregation activity: extracts from 31 Traditional Chinese Medicines with the property of activating blood and resolving stasis

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the anti-platelet aggregation effects of extracts from 31 Traditional Chinese Medicines(TCM) with the property of activating blood and resolving stasis in terms of TCM theory.METHODS: The 31 TCMs extracts were prepared using water, 90% ethanol and ethyl acetate., and the effects on anti-platelet aggregation were tested on a platelet aggregation analyzer in vitro with adenosine 5'-diphosphate, bovine thrombin and arachi-donic acid(AA) as aggregation inducers, respectively. Aspirin was the positive control.RESULTS: Lots of the tested TCMs had inhibitory effects with concentration-dependent manner on platelet aggregations induced by various agonists.Especially, some of the TCMs such as Chuanxiong(Rhizoma Chuanxiong), Yanhusuo(Rhizoma Corydalis Yanhusuo) and Danshen(Radix Salviae Miltiorrhizae) showed good anti-platelet aggregation effect similar or higher than that in positive control group.CONCLUSION: The study provided scientific references that several TCMs such as Chuanxiong(Rhizoma Chuanxiong), Yanhusuo(Rhizoma Corydalis Yanhusuo) and Danshen(Radix Salviae Miltiorrhizae),possess the property of anti-platelet aggregation.

Study on Oxygen Supply and Protection of Bone Marrow in Acute Radiation injured Mice

After irradiated by & Gy 60Co γ-ray, mice were intraperitoneally injected immediately with 0.2 ml 100 % compound blood-activating soup twice a day for 10 days. The in situ ulnar bone marrow partial pressure of oxygen (PbO2) was determined in vivo before, during and after irradiation respectively. The bone marrow sections in the same part were observed. Our results showed that the normal murine ulnar PbO2 was 12.72±1. 05kpa. During irradiation, the level of PbO2 decreased to 10. 78±1. 17 kpa (P＜0. 001). And 3 days after irradiation, PbO2 decreased to 9. 75±0. 52 kpa, suggesting that the commonly used 'blood-activating and stasis-eliminating' Chinese drugs could promote the rehabilitation and proliferation of bone marrow microvessels in the acute radiation injured mice, expand their areas, increase the oxygen supply of bone marrow microenviroment, thereby leading to PbO2 much higher increase than that of control group. It is also helpful in the proliferation and rehabilitation of hematopoietic cells.

基于虚瘀理论探讨补虚化瘀法在药物不全流产中的应用

药物流产因操作简便且创伤小等诸多优点,常作为早期妊娠终止方式之一在临床广泛使用,但药物不全流产并发症严重影响了女性对药物流产的接受度,尤其当部分残留蜕膜组织滞留宫腔日久,且组织物较多或机化需要清宫处理时,更是对女性身心再次造成巨创。文章基于对药物流产过程及产后生理特点分析,认为流产时失血伤津、元气受损,发生不全流产的根本原因为冲任受损,血不收摄;瘀行不尽,停留胞宫;或因虚致瘀,瘀血内阻既是病理产物,又成为新的致病因素,呈现虚中兼瘀,虚实夹杂的特点。综上可知,药物不全流产的病机为产后虚损,瘀阻冲任。鉴于此,文章提出药物不全流产的治疗应以补虚化瘀为根本原则,主要治法:①补虚固本、补气养血,使冲任得固,同时补气兼行滞,以防因虚致瘀;②活血化瘀行滞,但不宜峻攻,也不可过早止血;③攻补兼施,补虚祛瘀,以补虚不留瘀为原则,通过补气养血,祛瘀生新,使旧血不滞,新血得宁。总之,结合药物不全流产病因病机特点,给予补虚化瘀治疗可促进残留妊娠组织排出及子宫复旧,减少不全流产的发生,兼顾保护女性生殖及身心健康、保护生育力方面,发挥了中医的独特优势。

活血化瘀涂搽药治疗冠脉介入穿刺并发症临床观察

目的观察活血化瘀涂搽药剂外敷治疗冠脉介入穿刺并发症的疗效。方法选取2021年1月1日—2022年12月31日在江西中医药大学附属医院行冠脉介入治疗后伴桡动脉穿刺点并发症的患者100例,随机分为试验组和对照组,各50例。对照组采用50%硫酸镁湿敷,试验组采用活血化瘀涂搽药剂湿敷,均连续治疗7 d,比较2组穿刺部位淤青面积变化、穿刺部位肿胀程度、穿刺部位疼痛程度及临床有效率。结果2组患者淤青面积、肿胀程度及疼痛评分均较治疗前降低(P<0.05),且试验组均低于对照组(P<0.05),试验组总有效率高于对照组(P<0.05)。结论活血化瘀涂搽药剂外敷相对于硫酸镁外敷更能有效减少冠脉介入穿刺并发症患者的淤青面积、肿胀程度及疼痛评分,提高临床有效率,疗效好,值得临床推广应用。

蔡平平基于八纲辨证治疗绒毛膜下血肿经验采撷

介绍蔡平平教授基于八纲辨证治疗绒毛膜下血肿(SCH)的临床经验。在SCH的诊疗中,以八纲辨证为指导,强调阴阳辨证,灵活使用活血化瘀法;以“活血不留瘀、不动血、不动胎、不碍胎”为原则,提出“急则止血,缓则消瘀,澄源安胎为本”的治疗方法,同时宏观和微观相结合,重视脉诊。

费伯雄学术思想浅论骨肿瘤证治思路

本文在费伯雄的“醇正和缓,平淡和调”思想基础上的创新与发挥,阐述了中医对骨肿瘤的认识,将“固本清源”、“脾肾同治”“、费氏活血化瘀法”等应用于骨肿瘤辨证体系,对于“龙火汤”“立极汤”“后辛汤”“新定拯阴理劳汤”等进行创新应用,使其内涵与意义更符合现代中医药辨治肿瘤病的特点。在临床上灵活地按照肿瘤病发生发展的不同阶段分成了四期演变,并从病因、病机与治则方面辨治骨肿瘤发热以及骨肿瘤相关性失眠,在费伯雄学术思想指导下为临床骨肿瘤的诊治提供新思路。

活血化瘀穴位贴敷联合延伸护理对人工流产术后康复水平及生活质量的影响

目的:探讨活血化瘀穴位贴敷联合延伸护理对人工流产术后康复水平及生活质量的影响。方法:选取本院2022年1月至2022年12月收治的80例人工流产患者作为研究对象,应用抽签法将其分为观察组与对照组,各组均为40例。对照组实施常规护理干预,观察组在对照组基础上增加活血化痧穴位贴敷联合延伸护理。对比两组患者术后康复水平,并在护理前与护理1个月后对比两组患者疾病知识和负面情绪情况和评估两组患者生活质量。结果:观察组患者疼痛持续时间、月经复潮时间、阴道出血时间明显低于对照组(P<0.05);护理后两组患者避孕知识、生殖健康知识评分均升高,观察组高于对照组,HAMD,HAMA评分降低,观察组低于对照组(P>0.05);两组患者干预后生活质量相关评分均升高,且观察组高于对照组(P<0.05)。结论:活血化瘀穴位贴敷联合延伸护理可促进患者术后康复水平提升,减少患者疼痛、月经复潮和阴道出血时间另外能够进一步提升患者疾病健康知识,改善负面情绪,提升患者生活质量。

基于虚实辨证的大肠癌血瘀证中医药治疗和作用机制研究进展

血瘀证是大肠癌患者常见的中医证型,血瘀贯穿于大肠癌发生发展的各个阶段,活血化瘀法是临床治疗大肠癌的常用方法。从因虚致瘀、由实成瘀两个角度探讨大肠癌血瘀证的病因病机和临床治疗,并从增殖凋亡、血管新生、细胞自噬、侵袭转移、免疫调节、微循环障碍等方面综述活血化瘀中药治疗大肠癌血瘀证的作用机制,以期为临床使用活血化瘀法治疗大肠癌提供依据。

中药相关性肝损伤潜在可疑中药识别及临床特征分析

目的探讨通过医院大数据平台发现药物性肝损伤风险信号的方式,筛选出可能会诱发肝损伤的相关中药,分析中药相关性肝损伤的易感因素。方法收集2019年6月1日至2023年6月1日数据,对药物性肝损伤的诊断先确认存在肝损伤,其次除外其他肝病,再通过Roussel-Uclaf因果关系评估法(RUCAM)对药物与肝损伤的因果关系进行量化评估;再剔除合并用药中致药物性肝损伤使用化药(主要是A类及B类的药物)的住院患者,发现并整理出可疑中药品种,分为可能、有可能、不太可能、不可能4类。结果共收集肝功能异常患者2056例,筛选出可能中药相关性肝损伤患者142例,其中可能及有可能药物种类主要包括解表药、清热解毒药、活血化瘀药、祛风湿药等。结论可疑中药种类涉及范围较广,药物性肝损伤的发生可能与人体机体状态、药物本身有关,发生药物性肝损伤的机制可能与免疫炎症促进相关。

活血化瘀中药联合富血小板血浆改善激素性股骨头坏死的作用机制

背景:目前发现活血化瘀中药、富血小板血浆技术都能够修复受损血管,促进血管再生,重建股骨头内血运,恢复正常血供,进一步促进成骨作用,在早期干预激素性股骨头坏死方面均表现出一定的优势,可更加深入了解活血化瘀中药及富血小板血浆技术改善激素性股骨头坏死的作用机制,为今后治疗提供新思路。目的:根据国内外相关文献,综述活血化瘀中药联合富血小板血浆技术改善激素性股骨头坏死作用机制的研究进展。方法:检索PubMed、Web of Science、Metstr、中国知网及万方数据库收录的相关文献。以“中药、信号通路、激素性股骨头坏死、血管内皮生长因子、富血小板血浆”及“traditional Chinese medicine、signal pathways、steroid induced necrosis of femoral head、vascular endothelial growth factor、platelet rich plasma”分别作为中、英文检索词,检索文献时限为2000年1月至2022年7月,最终纳入相关文献75篇。结果与结论:活血化瘀中药及富血小板血浆技术在干预早期激素性股骨头坏死方面均表现出一定的优势。对于中医药而言,无论是活血化瘀单体药还是复方药都可以有效缓解激素性股骨头坏死疾病进一步发展,具体作用机制如下:①活血化瘀中药有显著抗凝作用,可以拮抗激素药物造成的血液异常(高凝)状态,进一步恢复股骨头内的正常血供;②活血化瘀中药可修复受损的血管内皮,通过激活血管内皮生长因子,使血管再生,重塑股骨头内血运;③活血化瘀中药祛瘀效果明显,可减少骨髓腔内的脂肪细胞堆积,缓解股骨头内压力;④活血化瘀中药可调控相关信号通路,维持骨代谢,促进成骨细胞、破骨细胞分化平衡,有效减轻激素性股骨头坏死。此外,富血小板血浆中含有大量高浓度细胞生长因子,对成骨作用及血管再生均起到正向作用,同时也可改善血液异常状态。活血化瘀中药联合富血小板血浆技术可发挥二者自身生物作用,干预效果更加显著。

活血化瘀方药调控水通道蛋白研究概况

张仲景提出“血不利则为水”的中医理论,指出了血与水之间的病理联系,即瘀血致水病机,为后世医家采用活血化瘀法治疗水液代谢障碍性疾病提供了思路,但其分子生物学机制尚不明确。水通道蛋白(AQPs)在维持机体水液代谢平衡中具有重要意义,当AQPs异常时,人体水液动态平衡被打破,可以引发多种疾病。近年来大量研究证实,活血化瘀方药可通过调控AQPs表达水平治疗脑水肿、肺水肿、便秘、组织肿胀等水液代谢障碍性疾病。基于此,拟通过综述AQPs在水液代谢障碍性疾病中的异常表达以及活血化瘀方药对其的调控机制,为“血不利则为水”提供分子生物学层面理论基础,以期为进一步研究及临床应用提供参考。

活血化瘀类中成药辅助治疗神经根型颈椎病有效性的网状Meta分析

目的:系统评价不同活血化瘀类中成药辅助治疗神经根型颈椎病(cervical spondylotic radiculopathy,CSR)的临床疗效。方法:应用计算机检索中国知网、维普网、万方数据库、PubMed、Web of Science和Cochrane Library中关于活血化瘀类中成药辅助治疗CSR的随机对照试验,检索时限均为建库至2023年9月20日。对照组单纯采用常规非手术方法治疗,试验组在对照组的基础上联合活血化瘀类中成药口服治疗。依据文献检索及筛选方案筛选出符合要求的文献后,由2名研究人员分别独立进行数据提取和质量评价。采用Stata18.0软件绘制网状关系图,对治疗有效率、颈部疼痛视觉模拟量表(visual analogue scale,VAS)评分、颈椎功能障碍指数(neck disability index,NDI)进行网状Meta分析,并根据累计概率排名曲线下面积(the surface under the cumulative ranking curve,SUCRA)对治疗方法的疗效进行排序。采用比较-校正漏斗图进行发表偏倚检验。结果:共检索到6768篇文献,通过逐层筛选最终纳入28篇文献,涉及颈痛颗粒、颈舒颗粒、脊痛消胶囊、痹祺胶囊、舒筋通络颗粒、颈复康颗粒共6种活血化瘀类中成药。网状Meta分析结果显示,在治疗有效率方面,不同活血化瘀类中成药辅助治疗CSR的疗效排序为颈痛颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=78.4%)>痹祺胶囊联合常规治疗(SUCRA=71.6%)>颈舒颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=62.1%)>舒筋通络颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=53.7%)>脊痛消胶囊联合常规治疗(SUCRA=43.3%)>颈复康颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=40.5%)>常规治疗(SUCRA=0.4%);在颈部疼痛VAS评分方面,不同活血化瘀类中成药辅助治疗CSR的疗效排序为舒筋通络颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=96.3%)>痹祺胶囊联合常规治疗(SUCRA=86.2%)>颈复康颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=51.6%)>颈痛颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=50.8%)>颈舒颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=37.4%)>脊痛消胶囊联合常规治疗(SUCRA=27.4%)>常规治疗(SUCRA=0.4%);在NDI方面,不同活血化瘀类中成药辅助治疗CSR的疗效排序为痹祺胶囊联合常规治疗(SUCRA=95%)>颈复康颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=71.3%)>颈痛颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=69.2%)>脊痛消胶囊联合常规治疗(SUCRA=38.7%)>颈舒颗粒联合常规治疗(SUCRA=20.8%)>常规治疗(SUCRA=5.0%)。结论:现有的证据表明,颈痛颗粒辅助治疗CSR的综合疗效最佳,舒筋通络颗粒在缓解颈部疼痛方面效果最佳,痹祺颗粒在改善颈椎功能方面效果最佳。但由于对照组采用的非手术疗法不尽相同及文献数量、质量等的限制,本研究的结论尚需进一步验证。