The role of the Sun in climate change is hotly debated.Some studies suggest its impact is significant,while others suggest it is minimal.The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(IPCC)supports the latter view and ...The role of the Sun in climate change is hotly debated.Some studies suggest its impact is significant,while others suggest it is minimal.The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(IPCC)supports the latter view and suggests that nearly 100%of the observed surface warming from 1850–1900 to 2020 is due to anthropogenic emissions.However,the IPCC’s conclusions are based solely on computer simulations made with global climate models(GCMs)forced with a total solar irradiance(TSI)record showing a low multi-decadal and secular variability.The same models also assume that the Sun affects the climate system only through radiative forcing–such as TSI–even though the climate could also be affected by other solar processes.In this paper I propose three“balanced”multi-proxy models of total solar activity(TSA)that consider all main solar proxies proposed in scientific literature.Their optimal signature on global and sea surface temperature records is assessed together with those produced by the anthropogenic and volcanic radiative forcing functions adopted by the CMIP6 GCMs.This is done by using a basic energy balance model calibrated with a differential multi-linear regression methodology,which allows the climate system to respond to the solar input differently than to radiative forcings alone,and to evaluate the climate’s characteristic time-response as well.The proposed methodology reproduces the results of the CMIP6 GCMs when their original forcing functions are applied under similar physical conditions,indicating that,in such a scenario,the likely range of the equilibrium climate sensitivity(ECS)could be 1.4℃to 2.8℃,with a mean of 2.1℃(using the HadCRUT5 temperature record),which is compatible with the low-ECS CMIP6 GCM group.However,if the proposed solar records are used as TSA proxies and the climatic sensitivity to them is allowed to differ from the climatic sensitivity to radiative forcings,a much greater solar impact on climate change is found,along with a significantly reduced radiative effect.In this case,the ECS is found to be 0.9–1.8℃,with a mean of around 1.3℃.Lower ECS ranges(up to 20%)are found using HadSST4,HadCRUT4,and HadSST3.The result also suggests that at least about 80%of the solar influence on the climate may not be induced by TSI forcing alone,but rather by other Sun-climate processes(e.g.,by a solar magnetic modulation of cosmic ray and other particle fluxes,and/or others),which must be thoroughly investigated and physically understood before trustworthy GCMs can be created.This result explains why empirical studies often found that the solar contribution to climate changes throughout the Holocene has been significant,whereas GCM-based studies,which only adopt radiative forcings,suggest that the Sun plays a relatively modest role.展开更多
文摘The role of the Sun in climate change is hotly debated.Some studies suggest its impact is significant,while others suggest it is minimal.The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(IPCC)supports the latter view and suggests that nearly 100%of the observed surface warming from 1850–1900 to 2020 is due to anthropogenic emissions.However,the IPCC’s conclusions are based solely on computer simulations made with global climate models(GCMs)forced with a total solar irradiance(TSI)record showing a low multi-decadal and secular variability.The same models also assume that the Sun affects the climate system only through radiative forcing–such as TSI–even though the climate could also be affected by other solar processes.In this paper I propose three“balanced”multi-proxy models of total solar activity(TSA)that consider all main solar proxies proposed in scientific literature.Their optimal signature on global and sea surface temperature records is assessed together with those produced by the anthropogenic and volcanic radiative forcing functions adopted by the CMIP6 GCMs.This is done by using a basic energy balance model calibrated with a differential multi-linear regression methodology,which allows the climate system to respond to the solar input differently than to radiative forcings alone,and to evaluate the climate’s characteristic time-response as well.The proposed methodology reproduces the results of the CMIP6 GCMs when their original forcing functions are applied under similar physical conditions,indicating that,in such a scenario,the likely range of the equilibrium climate sensitivity(ECS)could be 1.4℃to 2.8℃,with a mean of 2.1℃(using the HadCRUT5 temperature record),which is compatible with the low-ECS CMIP6 GCM group.However,if the proposed solar records are used as TSA proxies and the climatic sensitivity to them is allowed to differ from the climatic sensitivity to radiative forcings,a much greater solar impact on climate change is found,along with a significantly reduced radiative effect.In this case,the ECS is found to be 0.9–1.8℃,with a mean of around 1.3℃.Lower ECS ranges(up to 20%)are found using HadSST4,HadCRUT4,and HadSST3.The result also suggests that at least about 80%of the solar influence on the climate may not be induced by TSI forcing alone,but rather by other Sun-climate processes(e.g.,by a solar magnetic modulation of cosmic ray and other particle fluxes,and/or others),which must be thoroughly investigated and physically understood before trustworthy GCMs can be created.This result explains why empirical studies often found that the solar contribution to climate changes throughout the Holocene has been significant,whereas GCM-based studies,which only adopt radiative forcings,suggest that the Sun plays a relatively modest role.
