BACKGROUND:Botulinum toxin type A(BTX-A)is mostly to be used to treat various diseases of motor disorders,whereas its effect on muscle spasm after stroke and brain injury needs further observation.OBJECTIVE:To observe...BACKGROUND:Botulinum toxin type A(BTX-A)is mostly to be used to treat various diseases of motor disorders,whereas its effect on muscle spasm after stroke and brain injury needs further observation.OBJECTIVE:To observe the effect of BTX-A plus rehabilitative training on treating muscle spasm after stroke and brain injury.DESIGN:A randomized controlled observation.SETTINGS:Department of Rehabilitation,Department of Neurology and Department of Neurosurgery,the Second Hospital of Hebei Medical University.PARTICIPANTS:Sixty inpatients with brain injury and stroke were selected from the Department of Rehabilitation,Department of Neurology and Department of Neurosurgery,the Second Hospital of Hebei Medical University from January 2001 to August 2006.They were all confirmed by CT and MRI,and had obvious increase of spastic muscle strength in upper limbs,their Ashworth grades were grade 2 or above.The patients were randomly divided into treatment group(n=30)and control group(n=30).METHODS:①Patients in the treatment group undertook comprehensive rehabilitative trainings,and they were administrated with domestic BTX-A,which was provided by Lanzhou Institute of Biological Products,Ministry of Health(S10970037),and the muscles of flexion spasm were selected for upper limbs,20-25 IU for each site.②Patients in the treatment group were assessed before injection and at 1 and 2 weeks,1 and 3 months after injection respectively,and those in the control group were assessed at corresponding time points.The recovery of muscle spasm was assessed by modified Ashworth scale(MAS,grade 0-Ⅳ;Grade 0 for without increase of muscle strength;GradeⅣfor rigidity at passive flexion and extension);The recovery of motor function of the upper limbs was evaluated with Fugl-Meyer Assessment(FMA,total score was 226 points,including 100 for exercise,14 for balance,24 for sense,44 for joint motion,44 for pain and 66 for upper limb);The ADL were evaluated with Barthel index,the total score was 100 points,60 for mild dysfunction,60-41 for moderate dysfunction,<40 for severe dysfunction).MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:Changes of MAS grade,FMA scores and Barthel index before and after BTX-A injection.RESULTS:All the 60 patients with brain injury and stroke were involved in the analysis of results.①FMA scores of upper limbs:The FMA score in the treatment group at 2 weeks after treatment was higher than that before treatment[(14.98±10.14),(13.10±9.28)points,P<0.05],whereas there was no significant difference at corresponding time point in the control group.The FMA scores at 1 and 3 months in the treatment group[(23.36±10.69),(35.36±11.36)points]were higher than those in the control group[(20.55±10.22),(30.33±10.96)points,P<0.01].②MAS grades of upper limbs:There were obviously fewer cases of gradeⅢin MAS at 2 weeks after treatment than before treatment in the treatment group(0,9 cases,P<0.05),whereas there was no obvious difference in the control group.There were obviously fewer cases of gradeⅢin MAS at 2 weeks and 1 month after treatment in the treatment group(0,0 case)than the control group(5,2 cases,P<0.01).③Barthel index of upper limbs:The Barthel index at 2 weeks after treatment was higher than that before treatment in the treatment group[(30.36±22.25),(28.22±26.21)points,P<0.05],whereas there was no significant difference in the control group.The Barthel indexes at 1 and 3 months after treatment in the treatment group were obviously higher than those in the control group[(20.55±10.22),(30.33±10.96)points,P<0.01].CONCLUSION:BTX-A has obvious efficacy on decreasing muscle tension after stroke and brain injury,and relieving muscle spasm;Meanwhile,the combination with rehabilitative training can effectively ameliorate the motor function of upper limbs and ADL of the patients.展开更多
Objective:To observe the impacts of the combined treatment of Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion(moxibustion for promoting the circulation of the governor vessel and regulating the spirit)and rehabilitation training on the m...Objective:To observe the impacts of the combined treatment of Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion(moxibustion for promoting the circulation of the governor vessel and regulating the spirit)and rehabilitation training on the motor function recovery in the patients with apoplectic hemiplegia.Methods:A total of 50 patients with apoplectic hemiplegia and qualified in the trial recruitment criteria were divided into two groups according to random number table,25 cases in each group.In the control group,the simple rehabilitation training was provided.In the observation group,on the base of the treatment as the control group,Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion was given.Main acupoints:Baihul(百会GV20),Fengfu(风府GV16)and Dazhui(大椎GV14).The treatment was given once a day,6 treatments a week,4 weeks as one course and two courses of treatment were required.Before and after treatment,the scores of Fugle-Meyer assessment(FMA),the modified Barthel index(MBI)and action research arm test(ARAT)were detected before and after treatment in the two groups separately.Results:After 4 and 8 weeks of treatment,the scores of FMA,MBI and ARAT were all improved obviously as compared with those before treatment respectively in patients of the two groups(all P<0.01).After8 weeks of treatment,the score of each scale in the observation group was more obviously improved as compared with the control group(all P<0.05).The difference in the clinical therapeutic effect was significant statistically between the two groups(P=0.005).Conclusion:The combined treatment of Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion and rehabilitation training promotes the recovery of the upper limb motor function and improves the self-ability of living activities in the patients with apoplectic hemiplegia.The long-term effect of this combined therapy is superior to that of simple rehabilitation training.展开更多
基金a grant from the Tackle Key Problem and Planning Projectin Science and Technology of Hebei Province,No.052761224
文摘BACKGROUND:Botulinum toxin type A(BTX-A)is mostly to be used to treat various diseases of motor disorders,whereas its effect on muscle spasm after stroke and brain injury needs further observation.OBJECTIVE:To observe the effect of BTX-A plus rehabilitative training on treating muscle spasm after stroke and brain injury.DESIGN:A randomized controlled observation.SETTINGS:Department of Rehabilitation,Department of Neurology and Department of Neurosurgery,the Second Hospital of Hebei Medical University.PARTICIPANTS:Sixty inpatients with brain injury and stroke were selected from the Department of Rehabilitation,Department of Neurology and Department of Neurosurgery,the Second Hospital of Hebei Medical University from January 2001 to August 2006.They were all confirmed by CT and MRI,and had obvious increase of spastic muscle strength in upper limbs,their Ashworth grades were grade 2 or above.The patients were randomly divided into treatment group(n=30)and control group(n=30).METHODS:①Patients in the treatment group undertook comprehensive rehabilitative trainings,and they were administrated with domestic BTX-A,which was provided by Lanzhou Institute of Biological Products,Ministry of Health(S10970037),and the muscles of flexion spasm were selected for upper limbs,20-25 IU for each site.②Patients in the treatment group were assessed before injection and at 1 and 2 weeks,1 and 3 months after injection respectively,and those in the control group were assessed at corresponding time points.The recovery of muscle spasm was assessed by modified Ashworth scale(MAS,grade 0-Ⅳ;Grade 0 for without increase of muscle strength;GradeⅣfor rigidity at passive flexion and extension);The recovery of motor function of the upper limbs was evaluated with Fugl-Meyer Assessment(FMA,total score was 226 points,including 100 for exercise,14 for balance,24 for sense,44 for joint motion,44 for pain and 66 for upper limb);The ADL were evaluated with Barthel index,the total score was 100 points,60 for mild dysfunction,60-41 for moderate dysfunction,<40 for severe dysfunction).MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:Changes of MAS grade,FMA scores and Barthel index before and after BTX-A injection.RESULTS:All the 60 patients with brain injury and stroke were involved in the analysis of results.①FMA scores of upper limbs:The FMA score in the treatment group at 2 weeks after treatment was higher than that before treatment[(14.98±10.14),(13.10±9.28)points,P<0.05],whereas there was no significant difference at corresponding time point in the control group.The FMA scores at 1 and 3 months in the treatment group[(23.36±10.69),(35.36±11.36)points]were higher than those in the control group[(20.55±10.22),(30.33±10.96)points,P<0.01].②MAS grades of upper limbs:There were obviously fewer cases of gradeⅢin MAS at 2 weeks after treatment than before treatment in the treatment group(0,9 cases,P<0.05),whereas there was no obvious difference in the control group.There were obviously fewer cases of gradeⅢin MAS at 2 weeks and 1 month after treatment in the treatment group(0,0 case)than the control group(5,2 cases,P<0.01).③Barthel index of upper limbs:The Barthel index at 2 weeks after treatment was higher than that before treatment in the treatment group[(30.36±22.25),(28.22±26.21)points,P<0.05],whereas there was no significant difference in the control group.The Barthel indexes at 1 and 3 months after treatment in the treatment group were obviously higher than those in the control group[(20.55±10.22),(30.33±10.96)points,P<0.01].CONCLUSION:BTX-A has obvious efficacy on decreasing muscle tension after stroke and brain injury,and relieving muscle spasm;Meanwhile,the combination with rehabilitative training can effectively ameliorate the motor function of upper limbs and ADL of the patients.
基金Supported by Research Program of Anhui University of Traditional Chinese Medicine:2019zryb21。
文摘Objective:To observe the impacts of the combined treatment of Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion(moxibustion for promoting the circulation of the governor vessel and regulating the spirit)and rehabilitation training on the motor function recovery in the patients with apoplectic hemiplegia.Methods:A total of 50 patients with apoplectic hemiplegia and qualified in the trial recruitment criteria were divided into two groups according to random number table,25 cases in each group.In the control group,the simple rehabilitation training was provided.In the observation group,on the base of the treatment as the control group,Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion was given.Main acupoints:Baihul(百会GV20),Fengfu(风府GV16)and Dazhui(大椎GV14).The treatment was given once a day,6 treatments a week,4 weeks as one course and two courses of treatment were required.Before and after treatment,the scores of Fugle-Meyer assessment(FMA),the modified Barthel index(MBI)and action research arm test(ARAT)were detected before and after treatment in the two groups separately.Results:After 4 and 8 weeks of treatment,the scores of FMA,MBI and ARAT were all improved obviously as compared with those before treatment respectively in patients of the two groups(all P<0.01).After8 weeks of treatment,the score of each scale in the observation group was more obviously improved as compared with the control group(all P<0.05).The difference in the clinical therapeutic effect was significant statistically between the two groups(P=0.005).Conclusion:The combined treatment of Tongdu Tiaoshen moxibustion and rehabilitation training promotes the recovery of the upper limb motor function and improves the self-ability of living activities in the patients with apoplectic hemiplegia.The long-term effect of this combined therapy is superior to that of simple rehabilitation training.