Associative Tasks Computing Offloading Scheme in Internet of Medical Things with Deep Reinforcement Learning

The Internet of Medical Things(Io MT) is regarded as a critical technology for intelligent healthcare in the foreseeable 6G era. Nevertheless, due to the limited computing power capability of edge devices and task-related coupling relationships, Io MT faces unprecedented challenges. Considering the associative connections among tasks, this paper proposes a computing offloading policy for multiple-user devices(UDs) considering device-to-device(D2D) communication and a multi-access edge computing(MEC)technique under the scenario of Io MT. Specifically,to minimize the total delay and energy consumption concerning the requirement of Io MT, we first analyze and model the detailed local execution, MEC execution, D2D execution, and associated tasks offloading exchange model. Consequently, the associated tasks’ offloading scheme of multi-UDs is formulated as a mixed-integer nonconvex optimization problem. Considering the advantages of deep reinforcement learning(DRL) in processing tasks related to coupling relationships, a Double DQN based associative tasks computing offloading(DDATO) algorithm is then proposed to obtain the optimal solution, which can make the best offloading decision under the condition that tasks of UDs are associative. Furthermore, to reduce the complexity of the DDATO algorithm, the cacheaided procedure is intentionally introduced before the data training process. This avoids redundant offloading and computing procedures concerning tasks that previously have already been cached by other UDs. In addition, we use a dynamic ε-greedy strategy in the action selection section of the algorithm, thus preventing the algorithm from falling into a locally optimal solution. Simulation results demonstrate that compared with other existing methods for associative task models concerning different structures in the Io MT network, the proposed algorithm can lower the total cost more effectively and efficiently while also providing a tradeoff between delay and energy consumption tolerance.

Deep Forest-Based Fall Detection in Internet of Medical Things Environment

This article introduces a new medical internet of things(IoT)framework for intelligent fall detection system of senior people based on our proposed deep forest model.The cascade multi-layer structure of deep forest classifier allows to generate new features at each level with minimal hyperparameters compared to deep neural networks.Moreover,the optimal number of the deep forest layers is automatically estimated based on the early stopping criteria of validation accuracy value at each generated layer.The suggested forest classifier was successfully tested and evaluated using a public SmartFall dataset,which is acquired from three-axis accelerometer in a smartwatch.It includes 92781 training samples and 91025 testing samples with two labeled classes,namely non-fall and fall.Classification results of our deep forest classifier demonstrated a superior performance with the best accuracy score of 98.0%compared to three machine learning models,i.e.,K-nearest neighbors,decision trees and traditional random forest,and two deep learning models,which are dense neural networks and convolutional neural networks.By considering security and privacy aspects in the future work,our proposed medical IoT framework for fall detection of old people is valid for real-time healthcare application deployment.

Image Color Rendering Based on Hinge-Cross-Entropy GAN in Internet of Medical Things

Computer-aided diagnosis based on image color rendering promotes medical image analysis and doctor-patient communication by highlighting important information of medical diagnosis.To overcome the limitations of the color rendering method based on deep learning,such as poor model stability,poor rendering quality,fuzzy boundaries and crossed color boundaries,we propose a novel hinge-cross-entropy generative adversarial network(HCEGAN).The self-attention mechanism was added and improved to focus on the important information of the image.And the hinge-cross-entropy loss function was used to stabilize the training process of GAN models.In this study,we implement the HCEGAN model for image color rendering based on DIV2K and COCO datasets,and evaluate the results using SSIM and PSNR.The experimental results show that the proposed HCEGAN automatically re-renders images,significantly improves the quality of color rendering and greatly improves the stability of prior GAN models.

Optimized Identification with Severity Factors of Gastric Cancer for Internet of Medical Things

The Internet of Medical Things (IoMT) emerges with the visionof the Wireless Body Sensor Network (WBSN) to improve the health monitoringsystems and has an enormous impact on the healthcare system forrecognizing the levels of risk/severity factors (premature diagnosis, treatment,and supervision of chronic disease i.e., cancer) via wearable/electronic healthsensor i.e., wireless endoscopic capsule. However, AI-assisted endoscopy playsa very significant role in the detection of gastric cancer. Convolutional NeuralNetwork (CNN) has been widely used to diagnose gastric cancer based onvarious feature extraction models, consequently, limiting the identificationand categorization performance in terms of cancerous stages and gradesassociated with each type of gastric cancer. This paper proposed an optimizedAI-based approach to diagnose and assess the risk factor of gastric cancerbased on its type, stage, and grade in the endoscopic images for smarthealthcare applications. The proposed method is categorized into five phasessuch as image pre-processing, Four-Dimensional (4D) image conversion,image segmentation, K-Nearest Neighbour (K-NN) classification, and multigradingand staging of image intensities. Moreover, the performance of theproposed method has experimented on two different datasets consisting ofcolor and black and white endoscopic images. The simulation results verifiedthat the proposed approach is capable of perceiving gastric cancer with 88.09%sensitivity, 95.77% specificity, and 96.55% overall accuracy respectively.

Efficient Certificateless Authenticated Key Agreement for Blockchain-Enabled Internet of Medical Things

Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)plays an essential role in collecting and managing personal medical data.In recent years,blockchain technology has put power in traditional IoMT systems for data sharing between different medical institutions and improved the utilization of medical data.However,some problems in the information transfer process between wireless medical devices and mobile medical apps,such as information leakage and privacy disclosure.This paper first designs a cross-device key agreement model for blockchain-enabled IoMT.This model can establish a key agreement mechanism for secure medical data sharing.Meanwhile,a certificateless authenticated key agreement(KA)protocol has been proposed to strengthen the information transfer security in the cross-device key agreement model.The proposed KA protocol only requires one exchange of messages between the two parties,which can improve the protocol execution efficiency.Then,any unauthorized tampering of the transmitted signed message sent by the sender can be detected by the receiver,so this can guarantee the success of the establishment of a session key between the strange entities.The blockchain ledger can ensure that the medical data cannot be tampered with,and the certificateless mechanism can weaken the key escrow problem.Moreover,the security proof and performance analysis are given,which show that the proposed model and KA protocol are more secure and efficient than other schemes in similar literature.

Machine Learning-Enabled Communication Approach for the Internet of Medical Things

The Internet ofMedical Things(IoMT)is mainly concernedwith the efficient utilisation of wearable devices in the healthcare domain to manage various processes automatically,whereas machine learning approaches enable these smart systems to make informed decisions.Generally,broadcasting is used for the transmission of frames,whereas congestion,energy efficiency,and excessive load are among the common issues associated with existing approaches.In this paper,a machine learning-enabled shortest path identification scheme is presented to ensure reliable transmission of frames,especially with the minimum possible communication overheads in the IoMT network.For this purpose,the proposed scheme utilises a well-known technique,i.e.,Kruskal’s algorithm,to find an optimal path from source to destination wearable devices.Additionally,other evaluation metrics are used to find a reliable and shortest possible communication path between the two interested parties.Apart from that,every device is bound to hold a supplementary path,preferably a second optimised path,for situations where the current communication path is no longer available,either due to device failure or heavy traffic.Furthermore,the machine learning approach helps enable these devices to update their routing tables simultaneously,and an optimal path could be replaced if a better one is available.The proposed mechanism has been tested using a smart environment developed for the healthcare domain using IoMT networks.Simulation results show that the proposed machine learning-oriented approach performs better than existing approaches where the proposed scheme has achieved the minimum possible ratios,i.e.,17%and 23%,in terms of end to end delay and packet losses,respectively.Moreover,the proposed scheme has achieved an approximately 21%improvement in the average throughput compared to the existing schemes.

On the design of an AI-driven secure communication scheme for internet of medical things environment

The Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)is a collection of smart healthcare devices,hardware infrastructure,and related software applications,that facilitate the connection of healthcare information technology system via the Internet.It is also called IoT in healthcare,facilitating secure communication of remote healthcare devices over the Internet for quick and flexible analysis of healthcare data.In other words,IoMT is an amalgam of medical devices and applications,which improves overall healthcare outcomes.However,this system is prone to securityand privacy-related attacks on healthcare data.Therefore,providing a robust security mechanism to prevent the attacks and vulnerability of IoMT is essential.To mitigate this,we proposed a new Artificial-Intelligence envisioned secure communication scheme for IoMT.The discussed network and threat models provide details of the associated network arrangement of the IoMT devices and attacks relevant to IoMT.Furthermore,we provide the security analysis of the proposed scheme to show its security against different possible attacks.Moreover,a comparative study of the proposed scheme with other similar schemes is presented.Our results show that the proposed scheme outperforms other similar schemes in terms of communication and computation costs,and security and functionality attributes.Finally,we provide a pragmatic study of the proposed scheme to observe its impact on various network performance parameters.

Intelligent Intrusion Detection System for the Internet of Medical Things Based on Data-Driven Techniques

Introducing IoT devices to healthcare fields has made it possible to remotely monitor patients’information and provide a proper diagnosis as needed,resulting in the Internet of Medical Things(IoMT).However,obtaining good security features that ensure the integrity and confidentiality of patient’s information is a significant challenge.However,due to the computational resources being limited,an edge device may struggle to handle heavy detection tasks such as complex machine learning algorithms.Therefore,designing and developing a lightweight detection mechanism is crucial.To address the aforementioned challenges,a new lightweight IDS approach is developed to effectively combat a diverse range of cyberattacks in IoMT networks.The proposed anomaly-based IDS is divided into three steps:pre-processing,feature selection,and decision.In the pre-processing phase,data cleaning and normalization are performed.In the feature selection step,the proposed approach uses two data-driven kernel techniques:kernel principal component analysis and kernel partial least square techniques to reduce the dimension of extracted features and to ameliorate the detection results.Therefore,in decision step,in order to classify whether the traffic flow is normal or malicious the kernel extreme learning machine is used.To check the efficiency of the developed detection scheme,a modern IoMT dataset named WUSTL-EHMS-2020 is considered to evaluate and discuss the achieved results.The proposed method achieved 99.9%accuracy,99.8%specificity,100%Sensitivity,99.9 F-score.

Encryption with User Authentication Model for Internet of Medical Things Environment

Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)enabled e-healthcare has the potential to greately improve conventional healthcare services significantly.However,security and privacy become major issues of IoMT because of the restricted processing abilities,storage,and energy constraints of the sensors.Therefore,it leads to infeasibility of developing traditional cryptographic solutions to the IoMT sensors.In order to ensure security on sensitive medical data,effective encryption and authentication techniques need to be designed to assure security of the patients and healthcare service providers.In this view,this study designs an effective metaheuristic optimization based encryption with user authentication(EMOE-UA)technique for IoMT environment.This work proposes an EMOE-UA technique aims to accomplish mutual authentication for addressing the security issues and reducing the computational complexity.Moreover,the EMOE-UA technique employs optimal multikey homomorphic encryption(OMKHE)technique to encrypt the IoMT data.Furthermore,the improved social spider optimization algorithm(ISSOA)was employed for the optimal multikey generation of the MKHE technique.The experimental result analysis of the EMOE-UA technique takes place using benchmark data and the results are examined under various aspects.The simulation results reported the considerably better performance of the EMOE-UA technique over the existing techniques.

Energy and Latency Optimization in Edge-Fog-Cloud Computing for the Internet of Medical Things

In this paper,the Internet ofMedical Things(IoMT)is identified as a promising solution,which integrates with the cloud computing environment to provide remote health monitoring solutions and improve the quality of service(QoS)in the healthcare sector.However,problems with the present architectural models such as those related to energy consumption,service latency,execution cost,and resource usage,remain a major concern for adopting IoMT applications.To address these problems,this work presents a four-tier IoMT-edge-fog-cloud architecture along with an optimization model formulated using Mixed Integer Linear Programming(MILP),with the objective of efficiently processing and placing IoMT applications in the edge-fog-cloud computing environment,while maintaining certain quality standards(e.g.,energy consumption,service latency,network utilization).A modeling environment is used to assess and validate the proposed model by considering different traffic loads and processing requirements.In comparison to the other existing models,the performance analysis of the proposed approach shows a maximum saving of 38%in energy consumption and a 73%reduction in service latency.The results also highlight that offloading the IoMT application to the edge and fog nodes compared to the cloud is highly dependent on the tradeoff between the network journey time saved vs.the extra power consumed by edge or fog resources.

Deep Learning Enabled Disease Diagnosis for Secure Internet of Medical Things

In recent times,Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)gained much attention in medical services and healthcare management domain.Since healthcare sector generates massive volumes of data like personal details,historical medical data,hospitalization records,and discharging records,IoMT devices too evolved with potentials to handle such high quantities of data.Privacy and security of the data,gathered by IoMT gadgets,are major issues while transmitting or saving it in cloud.The advancements made in Artificial Intelligence(AI)and encryption techniques find a way to handle massive quantities of medical data and achieve security.In this view,the current study presents a new Optimal Privacy Preserving and Deep Learning(DL)-based Disease Diagnosis(OPPDL-DD)in IoMT environment.Initially,the proposed model enables IoMT devices to collect patient data which is then preprocessed to optimize quality.In order to decrease the computational difficulty during diagnosis,Radix Tree structure is employed.In addition,ElGamal public key cryptosystem with Rat Swarm Optimizer(EIG-RSO)is applied to encrypt the data.Upon the transmission of encrypted data to cloud,respective decryption process occurs and the actual data gets reconstructed.Finally,a hybridized methodology combining Gated Recurrent Unit(GRU)with Convolution Neural Network(CNN)is exploited as a classification model to diagnose the disease.Extensive sets of simulations were conducted to highlight the performance of the proposed model on benchmark dataset.The experimental outcomes ensure that the proposed model is superior to existing methods under different measures.

Blockchain-Enabled EHR Framework for Internet of Medical Things

The Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)offers an infrastructure made of smart medical equipment and software applications for healthcare services.Through the internet,the IoMT is capable of providing remote medical diagnosis and timely health services.The patients can use their smart devices to create,store and share their electronic health records(EHR)with a variety of medical personnel including medical doctors and nurses.However,unless the underlying commination within IoMT is secured,malicious users can intercept,modify and even delete the sensitive EHR data of patients.Patients also lose full control of their EHR since most healthcare services within IoMT are constructed under a centralized platform outsourced in the cloud.Therefore,it is appealing to design a decentralized,auditable and secure EHR system that guarantees absolute access control for the patients while ensuring privacy and security.Using the features of blockchain including decentralization,auditability and immutability,we propose a secure EHR framework which is mainly maintained by the medical centers.In this framework,the patients’EHR data are encrypted and stored in the servers of medical institutions while the corresponding hash values are kept on the blockchain.We make use of security primitives to offer authentication,integrity and confidentiality of EHR data while access control and immutability is guaranteed by the blockchain technology.The security analysis and performance evaluation of the proposed framework confirms its efficiency.

A Cost-Effective Approach for NDN-Based Internet of Medical Things Deployment

Nowadays,healthcare has become an important area for the Internet of Things(IoT)to automate healthcare facilities to share and use patient data anytime and anywhere with Internet services.At present,the host-based Internet paradigm is used for sharing and accessing healthcare-related data.However,due to the location-dependent nature,it suffers from latency,mobility,and security.For this purpose,Named Data Networking(NDN)has been recommended as the future Internet paradigm to cover the shortcomings of the traditional host-based Internet paradigm.Unfortunately,the novel breed lacks a secure framework for healthcare.This article constructs an NDN-Based Internet of Medical Things(NDN-IoMT)framework using a lightweight certificateless(CLC)signature.We adopt the Hyperelliptic Curve Cryptosystem(HCC)to reduce cost,which provides strong security using a smaller key size compared to Elliptic Curve Cryptosystem(ECC).Furthermore,we validate the safety of the proposed scheme through AVISPA.For cost-efficiency,we compare the designed scheme with relevant certificateless signature schemes.The final result shows that our proposed scheme uses minimal network resources.Lastly,we deploy the given framework on NDN-IoMT.

Vector Dominance with Threshold Searchable Encryption (VDTSE) for the Internet of Things

The Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)is an application of the Internet of Things(IoT)in the medical field.It is a cutting-edge technique that connects medical sensors and their applications to healthcare systems,which is essential in smart healthcare.However,Personal Health Records(PHRs)are normally kept in public cloud servers controlled by IoMT service providers,so privacy and security incidents may be frequent.Fortunately,Searchable Encryption(SE),which can be used to execute queries on encrypted data,can address the issue above.Nevertheless,most existing SE schemes cannot solve the vector dominance threshold problem.In response to this,we present a SE scheme called Vector Dominance with Threshold Searchable Encryption(VDTSE)in this study.We use a Lagrangian polynomial technique and convert the vector dominance threshold problem into a constraint that the number of two equal-length vectors’corresponding bits excluding wildcards is not less than a threshold t.Then,we solve the problem using the proposed technique modified in Hidden Vector Encryption(HVE).This technique makes the trapdoor size linear to the number of attributes and thus much smaller than that of other similar SE schemes.A rigorous experimental analysis of a specific application for privacy-preserving diabetes demonstrates the feasibility of the proposed VDTSE scheme.

Cognitive Computing-Based Mammographic Image Classification on an Internet of Medical

Recently,the Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)has become a research hotspot due to its various applicability in medical field.However,the data analysis and management in IoMT remain challenging owing to the existence of a massive number of devices linked to the server environment,generating a massive quantity of healthcare data.In such cases,cognitive computing can be employed that uses many intelligent technologies-machine learning(ML),deep learning(DL),artificial intelligence(AI),natural language processing(NLP)and others-to comprehend data expansively.Furthermore,breast cancer(BC)has been found to be a major cause of mortality among ladies globally.Earlier detection and classification of BC using digital mammograms can decrease the mortality rate.This paper presents a novel deep learning-enabled multi-objective mayfly optimization algorithm(DLMOMFO)for BC diagnosis and classification in the IoMT environment.The goal of this paper is to integrate deep learning(DL)and cognitive computing-based techniques for e-healthcare applications as a part of IoMT technology to detect and classify BC.The proposed DL-MOMFO algorithm involved Adaptive Weighted Mean Filter(AWMF)-based noise removal and contrast-limited adaptive histogram equalisation(CLAHE)-based contrast improvement techniques to improve the quality of the digital mammograms.In addition,a U-Net architecture-based segmentation method was utilised to detect diseased regions in the mammograms.Moreover,a SqueezeNet-based feature extraction and a fuzzy support vector machine(FSVM)classifier were used in the presented technique.To enhance the diagnostic performance of the presented method,the MOMFO algorithm was used to effectively tune the parameters of the SqueezeNet and FSVM techniques.The DL-MOMFO technique was tested on the MIAS database,and the experimental outcomes revealed that the DL-MOMFO technique outperformed existing techniques.

Study on Multi-Label Classification of Medical Dispute Documents

The Internet of Medical Things(IoMT)will come to be of great importance in the mediation of medical disputes,as it is emerging as the core of intelligent medical treatment.First,IoMT can track the entire medical treatment process in order to provide detailed trace data in medical dispute resolution.Second,IoMT can infiltrate the ongoing treatment and provide timely intelligent decision support to medical staff.This information includes recommendation of similar historical cases,guidance for medical treatment,alerting of hired dispute profiteers etc.The multi-label classification of medical dispute documents(MDDs)plays an important role as a front-end process for intelligent decision support,especially in the recommendation of similar historical cases.However,MDDs usually appear as long texts containing a large amount of redundant information,and there is a serious distribution imbalance in the dataset,which directly leads to weaker classification performance.Accordingly,in this paper,a multi-label classification method based on key sentence extraction is proposed for MDDs.The method is divided into two parts.First,the attention-based hierarchical bi-directional long short-term memory(BiLSTM)model is used to extract key sentences from documents;second,random comprehensive sampling Bagging(RCS-Bagging),which is an ensemble multi-label classification model,is employed to classify MDDs based on key sentence sets.The use of this approach greatly improves the classification performance.Experiments show that the performance of the two models proposed in this paper is remarkably better than that of the baseline methods.

Efficient Group Blind Signature for Medical Data Anonymous Authentication in Blockchain-Enabled IoMT

Blockchain technology promotes the development of the Internet of medical things(IoMT)from the centralized form to distributed trust mode as blockchain-based Internet of medical things(BIoMT).Although blockchain improves the cross-institution data sharing ability,there still exist the problems of authentication difficulty and privacy leakage.This paper first describes the architecture of the BIoMT system and designs an anonymous authentication model for medical data sharing.This BIoMT system is divided into four layers:perceptual,network,platform,and application.The model integrates an anonymous authentication scheme to guarantee secure data sharing in the network ledger.Utilizing the untampered blockchain ledger can protect the privacy of medical data and system users.Then,an anonymous authentication scheme called the group blind signature(GBS)scheme is designed.This scheme can provide anonymity for the signer as that one member can represent the group to sign without exposing his identity.The blind property also can protect the message from being signed as it is anonymous to the signer.More-over,this GBS scheme is created with the lattice assumption,which makes it more secure against quantum attacks.In addition,the security proof shows that this GBS scheme can achieve the security properties of dynamical-almost-full anonymity,blindness,traceability,and non-frameability.The comparison analysis and performance evaluation of key size show that this GBS scheme is more efficient than similar schemes in other literature.

DNBP-CCA:A Novel Approach to Enhancing Heterogeneous Data Traffic and Reliable Data Transmission for Body Area Network

The increased adoption of Internet of Medical Things (IoMT) technologies has resulted in the widespread use ofBody Area Networks (BANs) in medical and non-medical domains. However, the performance of IEEE 802.15.4-based BANs is impacted by challenges related to heterogeneous data traffic requirements among nodes, includingcontention during finite backoff periods, association delays, and traffic channel access through clear channelassessment (CCA) algorithms. These challenges lead to increased packet collisions, queuing delays, retransmissions,and the neglect of critical traffic, thereby hindering performance indicators such as throughput, packet deliveryratio, packet drop rate, and packet delay. Therefore, we propose Dynamic Next Backoff Period and Clear ChannelAssessment (DNBP-CCA) schemes to address these issues. The DNBP-CCA schemes leverage a combination ofthe Dynamic Next Backoff Period (DNBP) scheme and the Dynamic Next Clear Channel Assessment (DNCCA)scheme. The DNBP scheme employs a fuzzy Takagi, Sugeno, and Kang (TSK) model’s inference system toquantitatively analyze backoff exponent, channel clearance, collision ratio, and data rate as input parameters. Onthe other hand, the DNCCA scheme dynamically adapts the CCA process based on requested data transmission tothe coordinator, considering input parameters such as buffer status ratio and acknowledgement ratio. As a result,simulations demonstrate that our proposed schemes are better than some existing representative approaches andenhance data transmission, reduce node collisions, improve average throughput, and packet delivery ratio, anddecrease average packet drop rate and packet delay.

Design of Intelligent Mosquito Nets Based on Deep Learning Algorithms

An intelligent mosquito net employing deep learning has been one of the hotspots in the field of Internet of Things as it can reduce significantly the spread of pathogens carried by mosquitoes,and help people live well in mosquito-infested areas.In this study,we propose an intelligent mosquito net that can produce and transmit data through the Internet of Medical Things.In our method,decision-making is controlled by a deep learning model,and the proposed method uses infrared sensors and an array of pressure sensors to collect data.Moreover the ZigBee protocol is used to transmit the pressure map which is formed by pressure sensors with the deep learning perception model,determining automatically the intention of the user to open or close the mosquito net.We used optical flow to extract pressure map features,and they were fed to a 3-dimensional convolutional neural network(3D-CNN)classification model subsequently.We achieved the expected results using a nested cross-validation method to evaluate our model.Deep learning has better adaptability than the traditional methods and also has better anti-interference by the different bodies of users.This research has the potential to be used in intelligent medical protection and large-scale sensor array perception of the environment.

Priority Detector and Classifier Techniques Based on ML for the IoMT

Emerging telemedicine trends,such as the Internet of Medical Things(IoMT),facilitate regular and efficient interactions between medical devices and computing devices.The importance of IoMT comes from the need to continuously monitor patients’health conditions in real-time during normal daily activities,which is realized with the help of various wearable devices and sensors.One major health problem is workplace stress,which can lead to cardiovascular disease or psychiatric disorders.Therefore,real-time monitoring of employees’stress in the workplace is essential.Stress levels and the source of stress could be detected early in the fog layer so that the negative consequences can be mitigated sooner.However,overwhelming the fog layer with extensive data will increase the load on fog nodes,leading to computational challenges.This study aims to reduce fog computation by proposing machine learning(ML)models with two phases.The first phase of theMLmodel assesses the priority of the situation based on the stress level.In the second phase,a classifier determines the cause of stress,which was either interruptions or time pressure while completing a task.This approach reduced the computation cost for the fog node,as only high-priority records were transferred to the fog.Low-priority records were forwarded to the cloud.Four MLapproaches were compared in terms of accuracy and prediction speed:Knearest neighbors(KNN),a support vector machine(SVM),a bagged tree(BT),and an artificial neural network(ANN).In our experiments,ANN performed best in both phases because it scored an F1 score of 99.97% and had the highest prediction speed compared with KNN,SVM,and BT.