Acupuncture of different stimulation for the treatment of neck type cervical spondylosis:a randomised controlled trial

Objective:To observe the difference in clinical efficacy of acupuncture with strong and weak stimulation in treating neck type cervical spondylosis.Methods:64 patients with neck type cervical spondylosis were randomly divided into strong stimulation group and weak stimulation group,with 32 cases in each group.The acupoints selected are Jingjiaji 5-7(cervical acupoints EX-B2 C5-C7),Tianzhu(BL10)on both sides,Houxi(SI3)on both sides,Hegu(LI4)on both sides,Geshu(BL17)on both sides,and Ashi.In the strong stimulation group,deep needling with 0.25 mm×40 mm milli-needle was performed,with a mild reinforcing-reducing method.The twisting angle was 90°-180°,the frequency was 60-90 times/min,and the needles were applied for 1 min at each point.Keep the needle for 30 minutes,twisting was performed every 10 min during the retention period.Change hands once.In the weak stimulation group,shallow acupuncture with a 0.18 mm×40 mm milli-needle was performed,with a mild reinforcing-reducing method,with a twisting angle of 60°-90°,a frequency of 30-60 times/min,and acupuncture for 10 seconds at each acupoint.Keep the needle for 30 minutes,and no needle during the retention period.Patients in both groups were treated once every 1 to 2 days,3 times a week for 2 weeks,and followed up for 1 month after all treatments.The two groups of patients were compared before and after treatment and during follow-up.The McGill pain questionnaire score and the cervical spine dysfunction index score were compared to determine the clinical efficacy.Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 22.0 statistical software.Results:1 case drop-out in the strong stimulation group and 1 case in the weak stimulation group.The total effective rate of the strong stimulation group was 90.32%,the total effective rate of the weak stimulation group was 83.87%,and the total effective rate of the strong stimulation group was higher than that of the weak stimulation group(P<0.05).The total scores of the short-form McGill pain questionnaire,the VAS score,and the cervical spine dysfunction index scores of the two groups of patients were significantly lower than those of this group before treatment,and the difference was statistically significant(P<0.05).The total scores of the short-form McGill pain questionnaire,visual analogue scale score,and cervical spine dysfunction index scores of the strong stimulation group after treatment and follow-up were significantly lower than those of the weak stimulation group(P<0.05).Conclusion:Acupuncture with strong and weak stimulation can effectively treat patients with cervical spondylosis,and deep acupuncture with filiform needles and strong stimulation have better effect.

Blood-letting puncture and cupping at Dong's unique extra points for 65 cases of neck type of cervical spondylosis

Objective To observe the clinical effect of blood-letting puncture and cupping at Chōngxiāo（冲霄 Extra） point of Dong＇s unique Extra-ordinary points in the treatment of neck type of cervical spondylosis.Methods Sixty-five patients of neck type of cervical spondylosis were selected and treated with blood-letting puncture and cupping at Chōngxiāo（冲霄 Extra） point once every two or three days,three times constituted one course and two successive courses were given,then the clinical effect was evaluated.Results The curative rate was 69.2%（45/65）,and the total effective rate was 92.3%（60/65）.Conclusion Blood-letting puncture and cupping at Dong＇s Chōngxiāo（冲霄 Extra） point can be used to treat neck type of cervical spondylosis with simple manipulation and obvious efficacy.