This study aims to establish an expert consensus and enhance the efficacy of decision-making processes by integrating Spherical Fuzzy Sets(SFSs)and Z-Numbers(SFZs).A novel group expert consensus technique,the PHImodel...This study aims to establish an expert consensus and enhance the efficacy of decision-making processes by integrating Spherical Fuzzy Sets(SFSs)and Z-Numbers(SFZs).A novel group expert consensus technique,the PHImodel,is developed to address the inherent limitations of both SFSs and the traditional Delphi technique,particularly in uncertain,complex scenarios.In such contexts,the accuracy of expert knowledge and the confidence in their judgments are pivotal considerations.This study provides the fundamental operational principles and aggregation operators associated with SFSs and Z-numbers,encompassing weighted geometric and arithmetic operators alongside fully developed operators tailored for SFZs numbers.Subsequently,a case study and comparative analysis are conducted to illustrate the practicality and effectiveness of the proposed operators and methodologies.Integrating the PHI model with SFZs numbers represents a significant advancement in decision-making frameworks reliant on expert input.Further,this combination serves as a comprehensive tool for decision-makers,enabling them to achieve heightened levels of consensus while concurrently assessing the reliability of expert contributions.The case study results demonstrate the PHI model’s utility in resolving complex decision-making scenarios,showcasing its ability to improve consensus-building processes and enhance decision outcomes.Additionally,the comparative analysis highlights the superiority of the integrated approach over traditional methodologies,underscoring its potential to revolutionize decision-making practices in uncertain environments.展开更多
The primary goal of this research is to determine the optimal agricultural field selection that would most effectively support manufacturing producers in manufacturing production while accounting for unpredictability ...The primary goal of this research is to determine the optimal agricultural field selection that would most effectively support manufacturing producers in manufacturing production while accounting for unpredictability and reliability in their decision-making.The PFS is known to address the levels of participation and non-participation.To begin,we introduce the novel concept of a PFZN,which is a hybrid structure of Pythagorean fuzzy sets and the ZN.The PFZN is graded in terms of membership and non-membership,as well as reliability,which provides a strong advice in real-world decision support concerns.The PFZN is a useful tool for dealing with uncertainty in decision-aid problems.The PFZN is a practical way for dealing with such uncertainties in decision-aid problems.The list of aggregation operators:PFZN Einstein weighted averaging and PFZN Einstein weighted geometric,is established under the novel Pythagorean fuzzy ZNs.It is a more precise mathematical instrument for dealing with precision and uncertainty.The core of this research is to develop a numerical algorithmto tackle the uncertainty in real-life problems using PFZNs.To show the applicability and effectiveness of the proposed algorithm,we illustrate the numerical case study related to determining the optimal agricultural field.The main purpose of this work is to describe the extended EDAS approach,then compare the proposed methodology with many other methodologies now in use,and then demonstrate how the suggested methodology may be applied to real-world problems.In addition,the final ranking results that were obtained by the devised techniques weremore efficient and dependable in comparison to the results provided by other methods presented in the literature.展开更多
Intuitionistic fuzzy numbers incorporate the membership and non-membership degrees.In contrast,Z-numbers consist of restriction components,with the existence of a reliability component describing the degree of certain...Intuitionistic fuzzy numbers incorporate the membership and non-membership degrees.In contrast,Z-numbers consist of restriction components,with the existence of a reliability component describing the degree of certainty for the restriction.The combination of intuitionistic fuzzy numbers and Z-numbers produce a new type of fuzzy numbers,namely intuitionistic Z-numbers(IZN).The strength of IZN is their capability of better handling the uncertainty compared to Zadeh's Z-numbers since both components of Z-numbers are charac-terized by the membership and non-membership functions,exhibiting the degree of the hesitancy of decision-makers.This paper presents the application of such numbers in fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making problems.A decision-making model is proposed using the trapezoidal intuitionistic fuzzy power ordered weighted average as the aggregation function and the ranking function to rank the alternatives.The proposed model is then implemented in a supplier selection problem.The obtained ranking is compared to the existing models based on Z-numbers.The results show that the ranking order is slightly different from the existing models.Sensitivity analysis is performed to validate the obtained ranking.The sensitivity analysis result shows that the best supplier is obtained using the proposed model with 80%to 100%consistency despite the drastic change of criteria weights.Intuitionistic Z-numbers play a very important role in describing the uncertainty in the decision makers’opinions in solving decision-making problems.展开更多
The combination of fuzzy logic tools and multi-criteria decision making has a great relevance in literature. Compared with the classical fuzzy number, Z-number has more ability to describe the human knowledge. It can ...The combination of fuzzy logic tools and multi-criteria decision making has a great relevance in literature. Compared with the classical fuzzy number, Z-number has more ability to describe the human knowledge. It can describe both restraint and reliability. Prof. L. Zadeh introduced the concept of Z-numbers to describe the uncertain information which is a more generalized notion closely related to reliability. Use of Z-information is more adequate and intuitively meaningful for formalizing information of a decision making problem. In this paper, Z-number is applied to solve multi-criteria decision making problem. In this paper, we consider two approaches to decision making with Z-information. The first approach is based on converting the Z-numbers to crisp number to determine the priority weight of each alternative. The second approach is based on Expected utility theory by using Z-numbers. To illustrate a validity of suggested approaches to decision making with Z-information the numerical examples have been used.展开更多
There are numerous studies about Z-numbers since its inception in 2011.Because Z-number concept reflects human ability to make rational decisions,Z-number based multi-criteria decision making problems are one of these...There are numerous studies about Z-numbers since its inception in 2011.Because Z-number concept reflects human ability to make rational decisions,Z-number based multi-criteria decision making problems are one of these studies.When the problem is translated from linguistic information into Z-number domain,the important question occurs that which Z-number should be selected.To answer this question,several ranking methods have been proposed.To compare the performances of these methods,benchmark set of fuzzy Z-numbers has been created in time.There are relatively new methods that their performances are not examined yet on this benchmark problem.In this paper,we worked on these studies which are relative entropy based Z-number ranking method and a method for ranking discrete Z-numbers.The authors tried to examine their performances on the benchmark problem and compared the results with the other ranking algorithms.The results are consistent with the literature,mostly.The advantages and the drawbacks of the methods are presented which can be useful for the researchers who are interested in this area.展开更多
In this paper, we present an approach that can handle Z-numbers in the context of multi-criteria decision-making problems. The concept of Z-number as an ordered pair Z=(A, B) of fuzzy numbers A and B is used, where A ...In this paper, we present an approach that can handle Z-numbers in the context of multi-criteria decision-making problems. The concept of Z-number as an ordered pair Z=(A, B) of fuzzy numbers A and B is used, where A is a linguistic value of a variable of interest and B is a linguistic value of the probability measure of A. As human beings, we communicate with each other by means of natural language using sentences like "the journey from home to university most likely takes about half an hour." The Z-numbers are converted to fuzzy numbers. Then the Z-TODIM and Z-TOPSIS are presented as a direct extension of the fuzzy TODIM and fuzzy TOPSIS, respectively. The proposed methods are applied to two case studies and compared with the standard approach using crisp values. The results obtained show the feasibility of the approach.展开更多
文摘This study aims to establish an expert consensus and enhance the efficacy of decision-making processes by integrating Spherical Fuzzy Sets(SFSs)and Z-Numbers(SFZs).A novel group expert consensus technique,the PHImodel,is developed to address the inherent limitations of both SFSs and the traditional Delphi technique,particularly in uncertain,complex scenarios.In such contexts,the accuracy of expert knowledge and the confidence in their judgments are pivotal considerations.This study provides the fundamental operational principles and aggregation operators associated with SFSs and Z-numbers,encompassing weighted geometric and arithmetic operators alongside fully developed operators tailored for SFZs numbers.Subsequently,a case study and comparative analysis are conducted to illustrate the practicality and effectiveness of the proposed operators and methodologies.Integrating the PHI model with SFZs numbers represents a significant advancement in decision-making frameworks reliant on expert input.Further,this combination serves as a comprehensive tool for decision-makers,enabling them to achieve heightened levels of consensus while concurrently assessing the reliability of expert contributions.The case study results demonstrate the PHI model’s utility in resolving complex decision-making scenarios,showcasing its ability to improve consensus-building processes and enhance decision outcomes.Additionally,the comparative analysis highlights the superiority of the integrated approach over traditional methodologies,underscoring its potential to revolutionize decision-making practices in uncertain environments.
文摘The primary goal of this research is to determine the optimal agricultural field selection that would most effectively support manufacturing producers in manufacturing production while accounting for unpredictability and reliability in their decision-making.The PFS is known to address the levels of participation and non-participation.To begin,we introduce the novel concept of a PFZN,which is a hybrid structure of Pythagorean fuzzy sets and the ZN.The PFZN is graded in terms of membership and non-membership,as well as reliability,which provides a strong advice in real-world decision support concerns.The PFZN is a useful tool for dealing with uncertainty in decision-aid problems.The PFZN is a practical way for dealing with such uncertainties in decision-aid problems.The list of aggregation operators:PFZN Einstein weighted averaging and PFZN Einstein weighted geometric,is established under the novel Pythagorean fuzzy ZNs.It is a more precise mathematical instrument for dealing with precision and uncertainty.The core of this research is to develop a numerical algorithmto tackle the uncertainty in real-life problems using PFZNs.To show the applicability and effectiveness of the proposed algorithm,we illustrate the numerical case study related to determining the optimal agricultural field.The main purpose of this work is to describe the extended EDAS approach,then compare the proposed methodology with many other methodologies now in use,and then demonstrate how the suggested methodology may be applied to real-world problems.In addition,the final ranking results that were obtained by the devised techniques weremore efficient and dependable in comparison to the results provided by other methods presented in the literature.
基金funded by the Fundamental Research Grant Scheme under the Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia FRGS/1/2019/STG06/UMP/02/9.
文摘Intuitionistic fuzzy numbers incorporate the membership and non-membership degrees.In contrast,Z-numbers consist of restriction components,with the existence of a reliability component describing the degree of certainty for the restriction.The combination of intuitionistic fuzzy numbers and Z-numbers produce a new type of fuzzy numbers,namely intuitionistic Z-numbers(IZN).The strength of IZN is their capability of better handling the uncertainty compared to Zadeh's Z-numbers since both components of Z-numbers are charac-terized by the membership and non-membership functions,exhibiting the degree of the hesitancy of decision-makers.This paper presents the application of such numbers in fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making problems.A decision-making model is proposed using the trapezoidal intuitionistic fuzzy power ordered weighted average as the aggregation function and the ranking function to rank the alternatives.The proposed model is then implemented in a supplier selection problem.The obtained ranking is compared to the existing models based on Z-numbers.The results show that the ranking order is slightly different from the existing models.Sensitivity analysis is performed to validate the obtained ranking.The sensitivity analysis result shows that the best supplier is obtained using the proposed model with 80%to 100%consistency despite the drastic change of criteria weights.Intuitionistic Z-numbers play a very important role in describing the uncertainty in the decision makers’opinions in solving decision-making problems.
文摘The combination of fuzzy logic tools and multi-criteria decision making has a great relevance in literature. Compared with the classical fuzzy number, Z-number has more ability to describe the human knowledge. It can describe both restraint and reliability. Prof. L. Zadeh introduced the concept of Z-numbers to describe the uncertain information which is a more generalized notion closely related to reliability. Use of Z-information is more adequate and intuitively meaningful for formalizing information of a decision making problem. In this paper, Z-number is applied to solve multi-criteria decision making problem. In this paper, we consider two approaches to decision making with Z-information. The first approach is based on converting the Z-numbers to crisp number to determine the priority weight of each alternative. The second approach is based on Expected utility theory by using Z-numbers. To illustrate a validity of suggested approaches to decision making with Z-information the numerical examples have been used.
文摘There are numerous studies about Z-numbers since its inception in 2011.Because Z-number concept reflects human ability to make rational decisions,Z-number based multi-criteria decision making problems are one of these studies.When the problem is translated from linguistic information into Z-number domain,the important question occurs that which Z-number should be selected.To answer this question,several ranking methods have been proposed.To compare the performances of these methods,benchmark set of fuzzy Z-numbers has been created in time.There are relatively new methods that their performances are not examined yet on this benchmark problem.In this paper,we worked on these studies which are relative entropy based Z-number ranking method and a method for ranking discrete Z-numbers.The authors tried to examine their performances on the benchmark problem and compared the results with the other ranking algorithms.The results are consistent with the literature,mostly.The advantages and the drawbacks of the methods are presented which can be useful for the researchers who are interested in this area.
基金Project supported by the Brazilian Agency CNPq(No.309161/2015-0)the Local Agency of the State of Espirito Santo FAPES(No.039/2016)
文摘In this paper, we present an approach that can handle Z-numbers in the context of multi-criteria decision-making problems. The concept of Z-number as an ordered pair Z=(A, B) of fuzzy numbers A and B is used, where A is a linguistic value of a variable of interest and B is a linguistic value of the probability measure of A. As human beings, we communicate with each other by means of natural language using sentences like "the journey from home to university most likely takes about half an hour." The Z-numbers are converted to fuzzy numbers. Then the Z-TODIM and Z-TOPSIS are presented as a direct extension of the fuzzy TODIM and fuzzy TOPSIS, respectively. The proposed methods are applied to two case studies and compared with the standard approach using crisp values. The results obtained show the feasibility of the approach.